Original Articles

The contempt of Kayani court?


On Thursday, we saw a new anti-PPP decision from the so-called independent judiciary. Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani has been summoned to appear before the Supreme Court on February 13 for the framing of the contempt of court charges. This could be another sad moment of Pakistan’s fragile democratic history.

The conspiracy behind the memogate has mostly fizzled out rather quickly, and now court is using NRO as a cover for a deep-set enmity against an elected government: Independent analysts and observers say the court is trying to destabilize PPP-led government & oust President Zardari because of a conspiracy against democratic government. They also claim the Memo and now NRO case can’t be separated from tensions between the government and the army. And PPP sympathizers accused judges of plotting with the military to wage a witch-hunt against president and PM.

The reason for this is simple: plain arrogance, sense of supremacy & anti PPP mindset. Anti-PPP judicial military alliance tend to see civilian elected democracy as a “corrupt political system” that allows bloody civilians to loot national wealth.

In the past, the army has asked Pakistani civilian leaders to resign and influenced judicial proceedings against them. The military is also unhappy with the civilian leadership after a US commando raid killed Osama bin Laden in May 2011, but the army has ruled out a coup and is instead backing the courts to force a change of government or destabilize the democratic system.

The Judicial Military Alliance appears determined to destabilize the fragile democratic system, a conspiracy for power that has paralyzed the civilian government and distracted other pressing issues, mainly related to citizens and social services and Pakistan’s new democratic contribution in the South Asian region.

Deputy Speaker Sindh Assembly Shehla Raza has said the seven-member larger bench of the Supreme Court had already made up its mind for framing charges against the prime minister in the contempt of court case. Talking to media persons at the Supreme Court building, the Sindh Assembly deputy speaker said the court has given its verdict and now it is their right to speak on it. She was of the opinion that prime minister’s counsel Aitzaz Ahsan was not provided full opportunity to argue in the case.

Shehla Raza said that they have no intention to protest against the court verdict nor President Zardari would like that. She said they are not among those who are scared of short term decisions and pointed out that people are alive who were whipped for thousands of stripes. She said they suffered and went to the jail for democracy and they would continue to do so for the cause of democracy.

She said that perhaps the court remembered thousands of pending cases and therefore gave very little time to Aitzaz Ahsan.

Replying to a question about contempt of court, Shehla Raza said that since a verdict has come, she has right to speak on it. She said that that on 4th April, 1979, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was hanged on the basis of a court verdict and since then people of Pakistan were committing contempt of court by voting for the PPP.

She said the murderers killed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto but his ideology still remains. “We raise Jiye Bhutto slogan which means Jiye democracy and Jiye Pakistan” Deputy Speaker of Sindh Assembly said.—INP

PM’s lawyer Aitzaz Ahsan says “ the court should also hold those generals responsible for contempt who had not only dismissed judges but also arrested them along with their children.,”

President Supreme Court Bar Association Yasin Azad says the situation is moving towards a constitutional crisis “therefore all the institutions should keep in view the future of this country at every step.”

Though we have a democratic system in place, but I am tempted to say that the judicial military alliance is ruling in Pakistan, and its all about superior pride, irrational fear of democracy, and perhaps vindictiveness against PPP. This ‘independent judiciary and it’s judicial activism’ increasingly come at the expense of people’s representative democracy’, and widening gulf & rift between state institutions. Such sorts of anti democratic decisions, in the name of ‘judicial activism’ have devastating democratic consequences.

The leading democrats and liberals have lost trust in these courts and their selective justice; there is widespread criticism of selectivity in the application of constitution, we all wish the ‘independent court’ should show same sort of ‘judicial activism’ against creators & designer of NRO. Justice does not mean sparing powerful military dictators and targeting weak civilian elected representative. Listen seriously to the views of Asma Jahangir and Ali Ahmed Kurd. Today, the whole nation is standing behind the prime minister of Pakistan in facing establishments conspiracies against an elected government.

About the author

Dr Uzma Ali

18 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Heading given to this article is inappropriate. This is spreading lies and rumors. There is no Kayani court. This false allegation. Such accusations should be avoided

  • Poor article. Accusing judiciary and Army in support of PM Gillani is not a good idea. Court can summon anyone. What is wrong in it? What army has to do with it? Poor journalism

  • Curious as to why judges are not subject to impeachment by the people or elected representatives in Pakistan’s constitution? It appears as if they have lifetime terms and are not subject to any accountability whatsoever, which makes them easy targets for corruption and intimidation by the military.

  • Truthfully speaking … Military Chief and intelligence chief behaved very maturely in all that scenario…my Salute to General Kayani and General Pasha!!!

  • Why dont the writer just say” Supreme Court.. please dont disturb the elected government .. They are extremely busy in decimating Pakistan”.. Great Article.

  • sorry i dont agree with the writer . being a true pakistani i trust that the army has always done whatever was in the interest of country . its only the army who always saved the country , u may see the practical example of what army has done during the 2005 earth quake and 2011 flood

  • i dont believe such thing can happen … it seems a propagenda against the courts and army ….

  • i think what we as a nation lack is that we just criticize our institutions without any reason , we must stop this habbit of criticism for the sake of criticism . courts and military are the pillars of any nations

  • i think what we as a nation lack is that we just criticize our institutions without any reason , we must stop this habbit of criticism for the sake of criticism . courts and military are the pillars of any nations . i request to all patriot pakistanis to stand united against such mind spoiling articles

  • sorry i dont agree with the writer .This poor article is spreading lies and rumors. There is no Kayani court. This false allegation. Such accusations should be avoided.Being a true pakistani we should trust army.The army has always done whatever was in the interest of country.