Original Articles

Memo: PPP vs Judges Generals league


The year 2012 has begun with a rift between Pakistan’s fragile civilian government led by Pakistan Peoples Party and the all powerful military & inteligence establishment over a probe into the government’s role in a scandal centered on a unsigned memo that purportedly sought U.S. help in helping the fragile democratic government against the military take-over of power.

The memogate issue is a conspiracy orchestrated by the establishment against democratic institutions to regain the power to dictate the other state institutions and it is being helped by biased judiciary, irresponsible media & right wing political parties. The wife of former Pakistani ambassador Husain Haqqani, Farahnaz Ispahani rightly points out that the civilian government, elected president & former Pakistan’s ambassador Hussain Haqqani are not on trail, but in fact pluralism, democracy and civilian supramacy on trial in Pakistan

She writes, “The manner in which my husband, former Pakistani ambassador Husain Haqqani, is being treated in our homeland reflects the shrinking political space there for anyone who advocates positive relations with the West or stands up for religious-cultural tolerance and pluralism.”

The most powerful political force in Pakistan; the Military, with four bloodless coup; conspired against the people on several occasions by imposing martial laws and removing democratically elected governments, judicial murder of first elected prime minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto via Supreme Court & later killing of first woman prime minister Shaheed-e-Jamhoriat Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto, to it’s great credit. Now the same un-elected force is bent upon removing the duly elected government, by force unconstitutionally, and with the tacit support of judiciary on the pretext of an unsigned memo/ Khaghiz ka tukda. It was this institution that, on Wednesday, told the elected government that it should mind its language, or face “grave consequences” for the country.

The Economic Times report described this alliance the Pakistan Memo League; an alliance to oust yet another government in the country.

Pakistan’s leading opposition figure, Mian Nawaz Sharif, who has not learned from disastrous lessons of dictatorship. The most disturbing development is that he has decided to become a co-conspirator with the military establishment in yet another plot to dislodge a democratically-elected government. During his Turkey visit, he held a one-on-one meeting with Lt Gen Shuja Pasha in Istanbul in the last week of October wherein it was decided that the establishment and the opposition would work together to get rid of the PPP-led govt. And later he had a one-on-one meeting with the chief justice of Pakistan at his Murree residence and then he finally approached the Supreme Court. Some members of his Muslim league appear to have their own reservations against the former prime minister’s recent move and accuse him of conspiring against democratic regime. His party’s MNA Ayaz Amir openly criticized Mian sahib:

We have no doubt that the powerful Military is conspiring to make democratically elected Government as scapegoat along with Judiciary and Mian Nawaz Sharif as a co-conspirator.

Commenting on the memo issue, the Punjab Governor Sardar Latif Khosa said one cannot name the President, Army and Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) chiefs in a petition but they all accepted it because the petition was filed by Nawaz Sharif.

Meanwhile, the PPP is trying to draw democratic forces to its defence against the threat of the military establishment and a coup.

The prime minister of Pakistan Yousaf Raza Gilani has been talking to various political leaders and diplomats about potential threats to his administration and expressing fears that the army might stage a coup. The Express Tribune reported.

However, the PM House issued a flat out denial: “PM Gilani has not spoken to Thomson in this regard. The AP story is completely unfounded,” adding, “The democratic government, led by PM Gilani, draws its strength from the people of Pakistan – not from foreign powers.”

Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) former president & human rights activist Asma Jahangir says , “It appears that judges are playing the role of lawyers in the Memogate case, and the time will tell the nation that memo was mere a plain paper.”

“We want people’s government in the country, not the rule of Army and judiciary,”, She said.

The legal fraternity launched movement for the restoration of judiciary but the Judges wanted them back on their jobs only, she regretted.

She also said the Judges supposed that whatever they say was law but the law was written in the Constitution.

The memogate was not being probed by Judicial Commission but at a place in Rawalpindi. She added.

The following article written by Mohammed Hanif describes the biased role of establishment friendly media & so called ‘Azad Adliya’ as well as current situation clearly.

Pakistan’s army is using rumours where it once used force

As reports of a possible coup show, Pakistan’s army is as corrupt as the politicians from whom it wants to save the country

As the rumours of an impending coup circulated in Pakistan this week, an inquiry commission investigating the death of the journalist Saleem Shehzad submitted its report to the Pakistan government. The report has not been made public yet but members of the commission leaked to the press the only bit of information that mattered: the commission has fully absolved Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), the prime suspect in the torture and murder of Shehzad. Hours after his murder most of Shehzad’s colleagues and friends were convinced that it was an ISI job.

Another judicial commission is holding regular hearings to find out how Osama bin Laden managed to live near a military garrison in Abbottabad. Whatever this commission may or may not achieve, you don’t need to be an analyst to predict that it will absolve the army and its intelligence agencies of any culpability.

While a supreme court has been hearing, for years now, the cases of hundreds of missing persons, mostly Baloch activists who, their families allege, have been kidnapped by the military agencies. The bullet-riddled bodies of these activists keep appearing in the towns and villages of Balochistan almost every day. There is not a single bereaved family in the province that has any doubts about who is behind these killings. Yet, army officials, on the rare occasion they are asked, always throw up their hands in the air and say “Who, us?”

It was this institution that, on Wednesday, told the elected government that it should mind its language, or face “grave consequences” for the country.

This stand-off between the army and the government started over yet another investigation that the army is keen on. The army believes that President Zardari, through his ambassador in Washington, tried to lobby the US government to save himself from an alleged coup, after a memo emerged last October. The government denies it. The matter is in the court. Although the media is full of talk of sovereignty and honour once again, everybody seems to have missed the basic fact that in trying to save ourselves from a coup we have reached the brink of yet another coup.

Pakistan’s army has launched four coups and started and lost as many wars with India. Yet it still considers itself the sole arbiter of national interest and public morality. An army that’s not accountable to its own people is not a rare thing even in this day and age, but Pakistan’s army has the singular distinction of waging an almost continuous war against its own people and getting paid to do it. Pakistan’s army is as corrupt as the politicians from whom it wants to save the country. It’s just better at paperwork. If you are a politician in Pakistan you are likely to end up in a jail, or in exile, and in some cases hanged, or just bombed out of existence. If you are a general you are likely to spend your retirement years on a golf course paid by taxpayers, and own a holiday home in suburban Toronto. Pakistan’s president and prime minster may not be great leaders, but between them they have spent 15 years in jails, mostly under military rulers.

It’s easy for the army to give incompetent and corrupt politicians a bloody nose, but to come up with any remedies for an ailing country is another matter. And, lest we forget, it wasn’t the politicians who got this country into this fine mess.

The fact that instead of launching a coup the army has had to rely on rumours of a coup to deal with the government may be read as a sign that the Pakistan army is not as powerful – or shortsighted as it once was. But when it overthrew the last elected government, the then prime minister Nawaz Sharif had a two-thirds majority in parliament, and there was nobody clamouring for military rule. The army then stayed in power for nine years.

The classic garrison punishment for a new recruit is that he is asked to dig a hole in the ground. After the hole has been dug, you get a mound of earth which obviously looks unseemly in an otherwise spick and span training ground. Hence, very logically, the recruit is asked to dig another hole so that this earth can be disposed off. And then another and another till a time the recruit has learned his lesson. Pakistan’s army has turned this quaint little military routine into an elaborate ideology and transformed a promising country into a desolate land full of potholes.

About the author

Dr Uzma Ali

8 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Boomerang! Mansoor Ijaz did not appear before the Commission in spite of his tall claim he was reaching to testify. Mansoor Ijaz is the international version of (late) Khalid Khwaja. He has earned a lot on his mastery of posing to have very influential links with ISI, RAW, CIA and British Intelligence. India thinks he is a certified ISI man. He is an American citizen but he mostly resides in Morocco, which means he is not a desirable citizen of USA. He even fooled Indian government on the pretext he would solve the Kashmir issue between Pakistan and India.

    On top of this Black Berry has refused to provide the contents of Hussain Haqqani’s account.

    It would be interesting to watch what the Commission concludes in the absence of any material evidence. It is also a sad situation for Hussain Haqqani because he had tightened his belt to cross examine Mansoor Ijaz in the court to unfold the reality. Unfortunately,it will remain a skeptical story. About Establishment-Judiciary – PML(N)romance, yes it is quite visible. The rift between the Army and government has deepened as Army believes the tip of Osama Bin Laden to USA was provided by Asif Zardari. Therefore, ISI has been activated big time. Nawaz Sharif knows even if he played ISI game the ultimate beneficiary would be Imran Khan but NS does not care, he only wants to right his strained relations with Establishment. Judiciary’s mood is to unsettle Zardari but they do not want any PCO oaths. Establishment can not enter Islamabad with guns because this time there would not be any financial support from USA which is essential for a military rule in Pakistan. Their only hope is judiciary and mass rigging in the next expected early election. The heat is on.

  • I donot agree with the statement of the writer. He appears to be spreading false rumors against Pak Army. Such articles should be condemned

  • Such a baseless beginning of the article. Mr writer we have all the doubts. You are living under the load of perceptions and far away from reality. This democratically elected government is likely to stay till elections, your perceptions and your rumor machine is pathetic

  • I think the writer is hit by inferiority complex. It could be good if he was born in Somalia, so that he could feel the winds of prosperity.

  • But for the issue on makeup, here is a basic guide on how to shop for toxic free cosmetics:When it was confirmed, a plan was hatched to take Lincoln off and have him travel though Baltimore at night on an unmarked train. mac makeup uk ” What’s more, many of the ingredients are actually synthetically formulated, which takes “nature” right out of the picture, in a manner of speaking.However, before buying any kind of cosmetics online it is always wise to do some research first. mac makeup outlet Fall 2008 Beauty Trends From MAC CosmeticsIf nothing else, it’s a place where you can get away from the kids, the dog, and your spouse- and relax alone in peace. Wholesale Mac Makeup Redness is particularly hard to cover up with a plain foundation.Apply construction adhesive in a zigzag pattern to the back of the panel.

  • Pan-Cake was Max Factor’s 1st foundation that was sold for personal use.Apply concealer to under eye circles and blemishes. cheap mac makeup So what are the people saying about Boi-ing? Well some compliment how if you apply the right amount it doesn’t look cakey and doesn’t crease.There is a large concentration of iron oxide on Mars, thus giving it the red hue, and the nickname “the red planet”. cheap mac makeup In the past, women used to just look at catalogs and buy stuff without having the opportunity to get a look and feel of the product that helps you make up your mind.Trebuchet is another sans serif font, similar to Arial but with more character, although it can be difficult to read in small sizes.

  • Keeping these collections organized can be difficult, as it can require a proper order for each type of makeup to make finding each item easy, and allow for simple storage.Ideally, a moisturizing, anti-bacterial liquid soap is good for the brushes. wholesale mac makeup This all led to a trial run and I’m happy to report the results were everything we’d hoped they’d be.You need to know about this before you choose any skin care product. cheap mac cosmetics When it comes to the best storage device, external hard drive is the ideal choice.The lip color should be applied for creating fullness on your lips so that the attention from your square jaw line can be diverted. The amount of money spent on beauty products in this population market is significantly increasing.If you’re the type whose blush seems to evaporate no matter how many of layers of it you pile on, try a cheek stain.