Original Articles

Mullah Mohammad Fazl, responsible for Shia Hazara genocide in Afghanistan, about to be released by Obama administration


Adding to the miseries of Hazara Shias, who are already living under the severe kind of persecution and violence in Pakistani provincial capital Quetta at the hands of radical Shia haters i.e. likes of Malik Ishaq who had been released earlier this year as a result of so called peace deal between Pakistani security establishment and the banned outfits to placate the sectarian organization, Obama administration is all set to hand over another notorious Shia killer Mullah Mohammed Fazl to Afghanistan as part of a long-shot bid to improve prospects of peace deal in Afghanistan. Mullah Mohammed Fazl is a high risk detainee held at Guantanamo Bay military prison since earlier 2002. Mullah was held responsible by the UN for the massacre of thousands of Hazara Shias in Bamian and Yakaolang between 1998 and 2001 during the Taliban rule in Afghanistan.

WASHINGTON, Dec 29 (Reuters) – The Obama administration is considering transferring to Afghan custody a senior Taliban official suspected of major human rights abuses as part of a long-shot bid to improve the prospects of a peace deal in Afghanistan, Reuters has learned.

The potential hand-over of Mohammed Fazl, a ‘high-risk detainee’ held at the Guantanamo Bay military prison since early 2002, has set off alarms on Capitol Hill and among some U.S. intelligence officials.

As a senior commander of the Taliban army, Fazl is alleged to be responsible for the killing of thousands of Afghanistan’s minority Shi’ite Muslims between 1998 and 2001.

According to U.S. military documents made public by WikiLeaks, he was also on the scene of a Nov. 2001 prison riot that killed CIA operative Johnny Micheal Spann, the first American who died in combat in the Afghan war. There is no evidence, however, that Fazl played any direct role in Spann’s death.

Senior U.S. officials have said their 10-month-long effort to set up substantive negotiations between the weak government of Afghan President Hamid Karzai and the Taliban has reached a make-or-break moment. Reuters reported earlier this month that they are proposing an exchange of “confidence-building measures,” including the transfer of five detainees from Guantanamo and the establishment of a Taliban office outside of Afghanistan.

Now Reuters has learned from U.S. government sources the identity of one of the five detainees in question.

The detainees, the officials emphasized, would not be set free, but remain in some sort of further custody. It is unclear precisely what conditions they would be held under.

In response to inquiries by Reuters, a senior administration official said that the release of Fazl and four other Taliban members had been requested by the Afghan government and Taliban representatives as far back as 2005.

The debate surrounding the White House’s consideration of high-profile prisoners such as Fazl illustrates the delicate course it must tread both at home and abroad as it seeks to move the nascent peace process ahead.

One U.S. intelligence official said there had been intense bipartisan opposition in Congress to the proposed transfer.

“I can tell you that the hair on the back of my neck went up when they walked in with this a month ago, and there’s been very, very strong letters fired off to the administration,” the official said on condition of anonymity.

The senior administration official confirmed that the White House has received letters from lawmakers on the issue. “We will not characterize classified Congressional correspondence, but what is clear is the President’s order to us to continue to discuss these important matters with Congress,” the official said.

Even supporters of a controversial deal with the Taliban – a fundamentalist group that refers to Americans as infidels and which is still killing U.S., NATO and Afghan soldiers on the battlefield – say the odds of striking an accord are slim.

Critics of Obama’s peace initiative remain deeply skeptical of the Taliban’s willingness to negotiate, given that the West’s intent to pull out most troops after 2014 could give insurgents a chance to reclaim lost territory or push the weak Kabul government toward collapse.

The politically charged nature of the initiative was on display this month when the Karzai government angrily recalled its ambassador from Doha and complained Kabul was being cut out of U.S.-led efforts to establish a Taliban office in Qatar.

U.S. officials appear to have smoothed things over with Karzai since then. Karzai’s High Peace Council is signaling it would accept a liaison office for the Taliban office in Qatar – but also warning foreign powers that they cannot keep the Afghan government on the margins.

The detainee transfer may be even more politically explosive for the White House. In discussing the proposal, U.S. officials have stressed the move would be a ‘national decision’ made in consultation with the U.S. Congress.

Obama is expected to soon sign into law a defense authorization bill whose provisions would broaden the military’s power over terrorist detainees and require the Pentagon to certify in most cases that certain security conditions will be met before Guantanamo prisoners can be sent home.

The mere idea of such a transfer is already raising hackles on Capitol Hill, where one key senator last week cautioned the administration against negotiating with “terrorists.”

Senator Saxby Chambliss, the top Republican on the Senate Intelligence Committee, said such detainees would “likely continue to pose a threat to the United States” even once they were transferred.

POTENTIAL MAELSTROM

In February, the Afghan High Peace Council named a half-dozen it wanted released as a goodwill gesture. The list included Fazl; senior Taliban military commander Noorullah Noori; former deputy intelligence minister Abdul Haq Wasiq; and Khairullah Khairkhwa, a former interior minister.

All but Khairkhwa were sent to Guantanamo on January 11, 2002, according to the military documents, meaning they were among the first prisoners sent there.

Bruce Riedel, a former CIA and White House official, said Fazl was alleged to have been involved in ‘very ugly’ violence against Shi’ites, including members of the Hazara ethnic minority, beginning in the late 1990s, and the deaths of Iranian diplomats and journalists at the Iranian consulate in the northern Afghan city of Mazar-i-Sharif in 1998.

Michael Semple, a former UN official with more than two decades of experience in Afghanistan, said Fazl commanded thousands of Taliban soldiers at a time when its army carried out massacres of Shi’ites. “If you’re head of an army that carries out a massacre, even if you’re not actually there, you are implicated by virtue of command and control responsibility,” he said.

He added: “However it does not serve the interests of justice selectively to hold Taliban to account, while so many other figures accused of past crimes are happily reintegrated in Kabul.”

Some U.S. military documents – select documents have been released, others were leaked – indicate that Fazl denied being a senior Taliban official and says he only commanded 50 or 60 men. But the overall picture of his role is unclear from the documents which have become public.

Richard Kammen is an Indiana lawyer who has nominally represented Fazl; the detainee did not want an attorney.

“Based upon the public information with which I’m familiar, it would appear his role in things back in 2001 has been significantly exaggerated by the government,” Kammen said.

According to the documents, Fazl and Noori surrendered to Abdul Rashid Dostum, now Afghanistan’s army chief of staff but at the time a powerful warlord battling against the Taliban, in northern Afghanistan in November 2001.

While the men were being held at the historic Qala-i-Jani fortress in Mazar-i-Sharif, Taliban prisoners revolted against their captors from the Northern Alliance, the anti-Taliban coalition.

“Dostum brought (Fazl and Noori) to the bunker to ask the prisoners to surrender; detainee and (Noori) refused,” the detainee assessment from a 2008 document read.

Spann, a one-time Marine captain who was sent to Afghanistan as a CIA operative in the fall of 2001, was trying to locate al Qaeda operatives at the Mazar fortress among a large group of Taliban soldiers who had surrendered, according to the CIA and media reports at the time. When the Taliban prisoners began to riot – many of them were apparently armed – Spann was surrounded and killed. After a bloody, multi-day battle his body was later found booby-trapped.

Even a loose association between Fazl and Spann’s death – despite the fact there is nothing to suggest he was directly involved – is likely to increase the temperature of the debate in Washington.

What could be problematic for some Afghans is Fazl’s identification with the killing of civilians in central and northern Afghanistan.

“The composition and timing of any release has got to pay attention to Northern Alliance concerns,” Semple said.

Buy-in from supporters of that alliance – and from those wary of a resurgent Taliban – will be key in making a peace deal stick, if one can be had.

Despite the congressional concerns that released Taliban will return to the battlefield, Semple said it was unlikely even prisoners like Fazl – who truly was a significant military figure for the Taliban – would alter that equation.

“These people are not going to make a real contribution to the Taliban war effort even if they are able to go over to Quetta and rejoin the fight. It’s not risky in battlefield terms; it’s only risky in U.S. political terms.” (Additional reporting by Tabassum Zakaria, Patrick Worsnip and Jane Sutton; editing by Claudia Parsons)

Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/12/30/mohammed-fazl-hand-over-considered_n_1175333.html

According to the Wikileaks cable (http://wikileaks.ch/gitmo/pdf/af/us9af-000007dp.pdf) released earlier this year, the detainee (Mullah Mohammed Fazl’s) file tells that:

“Detainee was the Taliban Deputy Minister of Defense during Operation Enduring Freedom and is an admitted senior commander who served as Chief of Staff of the Taliban Army and as a commander of the 22nd Division. Detainee is wanted by the UN for possible war crimes including the murder of thousands of Shiites. Detainee was associated with terrorist groups currently opposing US and Coalition forces.”  

“Detainee and his mother moved from Uruzgan Province to Afghan refugee camps in Pakistan (PK) during the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan (1979-1989). In Pakistan, detainee received six years of religious training at the Rabinyah Madrassa in Quetta, PK”. 

“Detainee is an admitted senior official of the Taliban government and army and was last assigned to the position of Deputy Minister of Defense. Detainee also served as Chief of Staff of the Taliban Army and a commander of the 22nd Division. Detainee is wanted by the UN for possible war crimes including the murder of thousands of Shiites.”

 

“Detainee was implicated in the murder of thousands of Shiites in northern Afghanistan during the Taliban reign. When asked about the murders, detainee and AF-006 did not express any regret and stated they did what they needed to do in their struggle to establish their ideal state.” 

“Shortly after detainee’s surrender to Northern Alliance forces, Northern Alliance commanders discussed giving detainee amnesty. However, some Northern Alliance commanders strongly opposed amnesty for detainee, because he and Dadullah Lang were allegedly responsible for massacres at Yakawlang, Bamyan Province, AF, in which several hundred civilians were killed.” 

The longstanding conflict of Pakistani security establishment, The Taliban and Al-Qaeda, and the Americans in Afghanistan is thriving now at the expense of innocent Shias living under fear of death on both sides of Afpak border. Recent killing of around one hundred innocent Shias in Afghanistan on the occasion of Ashura, perpetrated by the LeJ-Alaalmi,  seems to be the tip of the iceberg that points out to the state of Shias getting wretched in coming days once the US troops leave Afghan land. To hand over the notorious convicts of Shia massacre in Afghanistan like Mullah Mohammed Fazl may end up in spate of sectarian violence in Afghanistan where Shias already are living as oppressed and persecuted community vis-à-vis in Pakistan where so-called peace deals with blood-thirsty monsters have brought a new wave of sectarian violence against Shias.

Video: Oppression of Hazara in Afghanistan

About the author

Maisam

14 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Documents and research related to the 779 people who have been sent to the Guantánamo Bay prison since 2002.
    Related Coverage From the Times »NPR:

    The Guantanamo Papers »OverviewDetaineesTransfer CountriesCitizenshipTimelineAbout

    Mullah Mohammad Fazl

    Mullah Mohammad Fazl is a 43- or 44-year-old citizen of Afghanistan. As of Dec. 27, 2011, he has been held at Guantánamo for nine years 11 months.

    http://projects.nytimes.com/guantanamo/detainees/7-mullah-mohammad-fazl

  • American is failing badly… fail, fail… at the end of the day he has killed many innocent Hazaras.

  • Yes, shame on President Obama, the current U.S. administration that was supposed to represent “change’- Obama just doesn’t get it. This is another outrage.

    As as American, I apologize to the Hazara and Shiite community if they release this evil, murdering slime.

  • Rusty bhai, your humanity and decency in accepting criticism of US policy should be lesson for the hypernationalist elites who dominate our discourse here in Pakistna.

  • i wan to say this that shia where ever they are living the reson which whom are on fire, just dew to this that they are innosence and even one shia or hazara are not terririst, and its the main reson which we are always on target list of terririst which are taliban lashkar jangvi and sipa e sahaba . shia hazara is peace full nation we apeal to the heuman right commision that help shia people and make save the life of this comeunity . even we are not save in afghanistan not here in pakistan , and if hazara stand up to get over right we know it well but we dont want any kind of terrirism any where , hop heuman right comesion will help uss thanks m mehdi

  • Really sorrowful and disapointable. We have faced many kind of oppression aganist taliban and F**King Rahman khan the Afghan President Cause being Shia. Those ethnics aren,t have any leader they are under of this kind oppression. It is just a policy of U,S however they are killing Shia and by side they are apologizing of Shia people. They made Suddam to kill all innocent Shia in Iraq and after they made Al-Qeeda to kill innocent Shia. America will soon dying by massive borrowed from other countires. my aim is not that America should die there is also living innocent people I mean the government and the political.
    Thank you.

  • Shame on Obama who never deserved a Nobel Prize for peace!!

    Why is Hazara blood so cheap???

  • This showes that US have its own conspiracy politics in the region and are still would like to use them inother forms for their own political benefits to put the region into chaos through them. They probably would be used as agent of threat to Iran and Pakistan that would be followed with many death of civilian. UN and Human Right entitities and Amnisty International must have a statement or consideration on this kind of decisions or move base on its impact in allignment with IHL, human rights. Otherwise the future human right voilation due to this move can be extensive. If International Community and UN, US are committed they should not have to release this people that is under their custody. Other wise they may have to use alot of money to arrest them. Instead they and their party Taliban should be introduce to International Crimanl Courts as international criminals.

  • […] Irfan Qadri ‎Hassan Turi Criticism of US: http://criticalppp.com/archives/40445 and http://criticalppp.com/archives/73545 andhttp://criticalppp.com/archives/67885 and http://criticalppp.com/archives/67049 and http://criticalppp.com/archives/66449 andhttp://criticalppp.com/archives/65386 and http://criticalppp.com/archives/63812 etc. An open letter to President Obama: People of Bahrain need your help | LUBP […]

  • Parce qu’il ya un espace accessible, je suis prêt à le dépasser. Cependant, en disant que je vais aller main dans la main quand il s’allume soudainement allumer la lumière à droite, première rangée légèrement à droite.