Original Articles

Military must surrender control of foreign policy – by Shiraz Paracha

Recent arbitration by the Saudi intelligence agency in the ongoing ‘CIA-ISI war’ is yet another proof that Pakistan is in a dangerous mess created by the military’s illegitimate control over the country’s foreign policy.

Before it is too late, Pakistan needs a radical change in terms of reorganizing  internal power centers. Adventurous generals must be reined in and should be no longer be allowed to impose their outdated foreign policy perceptions. As a significant stakeholder, the military can give advice on foreign policy issues but it must not solely shape or dictate the contours of Pakistan’s foreign policy.

A country’s foreign policy is formulated not on the basis of paranoia and true or false security concerns. Trade and economic interests are corner stones of a successful foreign policy. A country can’t change her neighbors; it has to live with them. A country which can’t establish friendly or at least working relationship with its neighbors is not considered credible by the international community.

Pakistan is seen as an unreliable state because its generals, not politicians; control the country’s foreign policy. The time has come that for the survival of Pakistan, and to restore its own credibility the military restrain from meddling in the foreign policy.

The majority of Pakistanis are not against India but a few generals are. The people of Pakistan would like to have good relations with India but the military is opposed to the public will. At the same time under the Saudi and American pressure the military has blocked bridge building efforts between Iran and Pakistan. This attitude of the men in uniform has been hurting Pakistan.  

 The military cannot continue treating the rest of Pakistanis as ‘bloody civilians’ or a heard of sheep. Pakistan needs an army that serves the people of Pakistan, an army that follows law of the land and submits to the writ of an elected representative government. Foreign policy ought to be formulated by the elected civilian government in consultation with properly trained specialists, professionals, academia and other stakeholders.

The military is not the sole interpreter of Pakistan’s national interests. The military is not the institution which should set national or international agenda for Pakistan.  

For the last 65 year, the people and all institutions in Pakistan have been hostages at the hands of their own military. In the past generals and commanders considered Pakistan as their personal state. Indeed because of generals’ horrific blunders lives of millions of Pakistanis have been at risk.

Intellectually confused generals like Ayub Khan, Sher Ali Khan, Zia-ul-Haq, Aslam Bag, Hamid Gul, Akhtar Abdur Rahman, Naseerullah Khan Baber, Javed Nasir, Pervez Musharraf and many more tried to implement their flawed perceptions and philosophies in Pakistan by force and manipulation.

Professionally incompetent generals, many of whom were also corrupt and morally bankrupt, put their personal greed and ambitions above Pakistan. Today, the Pakistani society is a sick society due to paranoia and confusions created by a few generals.

The military’s civilian regiments such as the Jamat-e-Islami and other Jihadies have imposed false ideologies and concepts upon the people of Pakistan. Even today, a group of idiots defends those foolish and deadly policies on our television screens. As a consequence Pakistan’s faces a huge PR crisis.

The military has been involved in clandestine operations and deals and often the country’s civilian leadership is not informed. In fact an independent investigation would reveal that some in the Pakistan military have been pursuing criminal agendas at the cost of  Pakistan and its people.  Military coups and generals’ unlawful interference in foreign and domestic policies have harmed Pakistan. Some Pakistani generals think that only they know what is good for Pakistan. This selfish and foolish approach has almost destroyed Pakistan.

It is sad to observe that despite recent debacles no lessons have been learnt and there are no visible signs of change in the military mindset. Discussions and the tone at Corps Commanders’ meetings have not been appropriate. Corps Commanders act as an alternative Cabinet and generals present themselves as defective rulers of Pakistan. With military’s such behavior Pakistan will continue suffering humiliation after humiliation on the national and international fronts.

The current military leadership can turn the page.  General Ashfaq Parvez Kayani and his colleagues can change the culture of contempt that exists in the military ranks for the Parliament and the elected government. General Kayani will earn true respect and will leave a positive legacy behind if he could take the first step and teaches his fellow commanders that they have to bow to the will of the people and obey the law, not violate it. Half of the Pakistan’s troubles can end if some in its military stop operating above and beyond the law.

Shiraz Paracha is a journalist and analyst. He can be reached at: shiraz_paracha@hotmail.com

About the author

Shiraz Paracha

Mr. Paracha has worked as a journalist, with newspapers, television, radio and online companies in Britain, Central Asia and Pakistan. Between 1995 and1996, hosted and presented very popular television programs (Awami Forum and Awami Jirga) in Pakistan. His former employers include the BBC and Press TV among other notable names. Mr. Paracha is also a journalism professor and has taught journalism and communication courses at international universities outside Pakistan.

5 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Grapes are sour. Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Pakistan military will never surrender its power!

  • if military generals are that much in control then why ppp government gave them extensions?…kia yeh khula tazad nahin..hypocracy at its best na

  • Sorry to say that I have to oppose your article on every ground. First of all i would like to say that Pak-Army is the only department in our country which is highly disciplined and organised and walks on footsteps of Quaid-i-Azam i.e Unity, Faith and Discipline. Alternate this case, do we see these traits in politicians since 1958. You must know that it was the civilian govt inability during 1950 to 58 who invited the military personals to assist them in governing the state affairs. Why Ghulam Muhammad made Ayoub Khan as the member of his cabinet?
    Secondly regarding the recent Army role in Foreign Policy of Pakistan, I would again speak on behalf of Army role in it. Are the civlian leaders that much trained and intelligent to cope the foreign affairs? No, not at all. Civil Leadership as well as beaurucartes had left a very bad impression in corruption and Merit based decisions, so how can one hand them over the foreign affairs, which would be tantamonut sucidal act. Is the cival leadership reliable enough to be trusted. I am afraid that they may not sell Pakistan or a part of it to Inida or US. Those leaders who sons and daughters are educating in foreighn universitites and their bank balances lies outside the country, can they think good for pakistan. It is not logical Sir! If these civil leadership is quit patriotic to Pakistan,then they should bring their assets to Pakistan and must muddled out Pakistan of the present day crisis. Then we can think for it that they must be relied upon for they have a patriotic blood in their vains. Otherwis, my friend I would suggest you not to play the tune of the time rather be a realist and think realisticaly. I am Not opposing to democracy or role of civilian in governance of state but its need of the time to bring a revolutionry change and revolutionary leadership to Pakistan to alter the entire statum of Pakistan.

  • Truth sahab,
    PPP is the biggest khula tazad! The only reason it has survived 3 and half years, is because of reconciliation with all power bases!!!!

  • If the foreign policy is controlled by Zardari- Gilani nexus then the following will happen:

    1) Festival of Eid will be replaced by Gunpati Pooja and Deewali.

    2) Billions of Rupees will be spent on making of portraits of international leaders ( with their wives of course and their legitimate / illegitimate children )

    3) Sarah Pauline will replace Mohtarma fatima Jinnah.

    4) Groping breasts will become official in parliament national assembly ( reference gillani-sheery rehman incident )

    5) Defense society, gulshan , Pechs , landhi , korangi will become separate provinces.

    6) Edison will be requested to reinvent bulb in pakistan.