Blogs Cross posted Original Articles

Constructing a ‘Secular’ Jinnah: New Project for Pakistani Liberals -by Marvi Sirmed

Originally Published at: BAAGHI

As a firm believer in cultural roots rather than oneness through religion, August gives me hope. Flags adorn the cities and marketplaces fill up with the echoes of milli naghmas (patriotic songs) sung in the 1960s and 70s. The country is engulfed by a sense of patriotic love for the soil. One, however, enjoys the irony of a nation that seeks its origins in the dreams of a poet with many kinds of messages. On the one hand a state is termed anarchist (Changezi) if its politics is separated from the faith (deen). On the other, one sees the warning against patriotic nationalism as a bigger dogma that might become the death of religion — Inn taaza khudaa’on mein barra sab se watan hai; jo perahan iss ka hai woh mazhab ka kafan hai (Country/homeland is the biggest among these new gods; What is its dress is the shroud/death of religion). Notwithstanding these contradictions, patriotic zeal (as against xenophobia) does energise an ordinary Pakistani, pressed under the burden of so many crises of identity, origin and relationship with the outside world.

Jinnah’s Pakistan turns 64 this August, having already enjoyed superannuation of four years from the standard retirement age. Ailing, weak, being on life support, today’s Pakistan is struggling to achieve a sense of national pride, proving to the world that it is indeed a reasonable international actor to reckon with and has a right to survival. What makes the struggle vain is a terribly wrong prescription and even wrong diagnosis. Civil-military relations and lack of democratic values are symptoms, the treatment of which could only slightly improve the quality of life. Retirement of Jinnah’s Pakistan is due. Let the new Pakistan take birth.

Having seen the ruins of a Pakistan dreamt of by Iqbal if it were (I have already written on how this claim has been discredited on these pages two weeks ago), or pursued by Jinnah, or executed by Liaquat Ali Khan and other Leaguers after Jinnah’s death, the ‘liberals’ (using the term in the strictly South Asian sense) of Pakistan have probably found a solution, i.e. constructing a brand-new secular Jinnah who had an exemplary vision of what Pakistan should look like, and who was succeeded by ill-intentioned and shortsighted leaders with loaded agendas. It is, according to the neo-liberal movement of Pakistan, the failure of these post-Jinnah politicians and civil and military leadership that the country has fallen into the abyss of religious intolerance, to euphemise Pakistan’s problem.

My problem with this thesis is not one. It presupposes so many notions without a critical objective examination of history. The most important myth our neo-liberals are creating is, Jinnah was an unquestioned secular person. Two, Jinnah had a clear vision about the future nature of the state of Pakistan. Three, Jinnah had passed on his vision to people or at least other leaders of his Muslim League who had to hold the fort after him (just to remind my readers, he knew what he was suffering from and how long he was going to live). Four, all the leaders of the Muslim League and those who came to power in subsequent years, were either shortsighted or had loaded agendas, save Jinnah. Five, the present chaos is the product of post-independence politics and not the pre-partition power play. And six, by constructing a secular Jinnah, this religious madness can still be countered and cut down.

It is most disappointing that even a liberal mind in Pakistan is ready to rescind the truth when it comes to perceived temporary gains. Deconstruction of all these myths requires many pages on each prescribed myth. I would confine myself, considering the limited space on this page, to the first killer assumption. By very definition, a secular person would be someone who refuses to entertain religion in politics and the business of the state. Yes we have the much trumpeted August 11, 1947 speech by Jinnah made to the first session of the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan as the Governor General-designate. The part frequently referred to as a secular pronouncement did not sound any different from what Maulana Maududi had been saying on minorities. “Granting” freedom to the minorities to go to their temples, etc, was probably a late realisation of the fact that the sanity of a state built on religious grounds could not be guaranteed. Having fought the battle for a separate state for the Muslim minority on the logic that it could not coexist with the majority, Jinnah pleads to the nascent nation to ‘bury the past’ and let the minorities live peacefully. Do we smell the problem here?

The adoption of a song written by a Hindu as the national anthem of Pakistan by Jinnah (later changed to the present more exclusive one) could have been a saving grace if a national flag did not have a separate strip for minorities that ultimately gets pierced with the baton. The ‘separateness’ so celebrated by the national flag quickly got integrated into the social and political discourse, where minorities were ‘equal citizens’ on paper but had to pay jiziya (an additional tax that religious minorities are liable to in an Islamic state) in terms of social space, status and opportunities.

Jinnah’s taste for western apparel, pets and aversion to religious rituals can or cannot be taken as his ‘secular’ credentials depending upon how you want to use Jinnah. But as a matter of fact, all these arguments do not hold much ground keeping in view his many assertions and promises with different political actors before, during and after the 1946 elections. In his book, Pakistan: The Formative Phase 1857-1948, Prof Khalid Bin Sayeed quotes Jinnah assuring some religious leaders who demanded Islamic law in the new state. Jinnah says: “…Constituent Assembly…will be predominantly Muslim…and would be able to enact laws for the Muslims not inconsistence with Shariah Laws and the Muslims will no longer be obliged by un-Islamic laws…” Professor Sayeed goes on to describe how the public rallies looked when Jinnah addressed them: “Islam with its symbols and slogans figured very prominently in all his speeches.”

Addressing a Pathan gathering, Jinnah once said amidst the shouts of Allah-o-Akbar (God is Great), quotes Professor Sayeed, “If we fail to realise our duty today, you will be reduced to the status of Sudras (low caste Hindus) and Islam will be vanquished from India. I shall never allow Muslims to be slaves of Hindus.” His words were taken over by loud shouts of Allah-o-Akbar.

Jinnah’s famous letter to Pir sahib of Manki Sharif, quoted in the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan Debates, Volume 5, 1949, p 46, in which he promised that shariah will be applied to the affairs of the Muslim community, is another recorded evidence of how Jinnah’s politics post-1940 had blurred a predominantly Muslim nation-state and an Islamic state. The amount of secularism in his politics equalled the possibility of pigs flying and Andres Breivik (right-wing extremist and perpetrator of the Norway terrorist attacks) converting to Islam.

It is, thus, advisable for Pakistan’s liberals to stick to the truth, which is the only panacea left for Pakistan. Whether Jinnah endorsed it or not, being a secular state is to Pakistan’s best benefit. What Jinnah said or did not say more than half a century ago is hardly relevant to the solution of Pakistan’s current problems (although they are strongly rooted there). Today’s industrialised India understood it quite well while deciphering Gandhi ji’s emphasis on handlooms rather than modern technology.

Postscript: Insistence on continuing with a wrong date as the birthday of Pakistan, just to make us distinct from India, would only perpetuate the sense of odium between the two nations. Happy 64th birthday Pakistan, which is today, August 15th!

About the author

Farhad Jarral

57 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Problem is that those who want deen and syasat hand in hand and a different kind of changezi; they always need to distort past to fit and suit the future they need, for instance check web site of Jamaat-e-Islami, contrary to what we are told, they tell us story of a Pakistan dreamed by Maududi and how Jamaat had influenced Jinnah.
    Now question is will it be appropriate to accept these claims or is it necessary to challenge them?
    And that is why one needs to continue to work on what happened half a century ago. Many of our believes and conventional wisdom or attempts to create that conventional wisdom for us, are deep rooted in our past; and without knowing the past it is impossible to challenge them.
    Jinnah in this scenario will always be claimed by different groups, what is really required is to create true knowledge base for people, hard work to spread knowledge and keenness in people to seek truth without bias, there were and there are such societies; if we can create one, Jinnah will be able to stood as he was. A leader of Musalmans of India with a career spreading across several decades with all ups and downs, mistakes as well as success.

  • This woman has found a different way to get popularity! to demoralise the Pakistani nation. Whatever show wrote is irrelevant. All references she gave are absolutely FALSE.
    I think marvi could find a better place in heera mandi with some due respect

  • Great, i am very happy that this has been written. Its mpost important to deconstruct this myth of seculat Jinnah. Unfortunately during Zia era the left wing historians build a narrative to counter Zia’s cultural Islamization where western side of Jinnah was over emphasized , his wearing of suit, lack of beard and taste of Whisky because these were the things on which Ziaist state was judging people. When these text were taken on by over new middle class liberals they were interpreted in a ahistoric way and some times ain a non historic way to create a Jinnah of Utopian proportions and a utopian land known as Jinnah’s Pakistan which was nothing unfortunately but a shrine for already existing national security arrangement of islamic republic
    The issue of National Anthem written by a Hinda appears to be a myth. There is no evidence that such an anthem was aired in Pakistan or Jinnah asked him to write. A book has come into arket whch shoes a complete lack of evidence in this matter. The issue was carelessly promoted by the liberal elitist writers of Pakistan. These people are not liberals actually, they are Pakistani nationalists who relate to the culture of colonial muslim elite, which was westerized in their living condition but kept the muslim prejudices and communal mindset intact.
    welldone Marvi

  • I AM NAUSATED WITH THE MEDIOCRICITY … ANOTHER GAHAZI ILAM DIN WILL RISE AND KILL…. THATS AS FAR AS WE CAN GO OUR VISION IS MYOPIC SIGHT ENDS WEHRE THE BONET OF YOUR CAR SIEZES THATS HOW WE HAVE BEEN TRANSFORMED ( READ DEGENERRATED ) INTO REGISTERING A PROTEST LOOK AROUND YOU IF YOU LIVE IN KARACHI ….. ALL THE BEST PROTEST YOU GET IS A CRAZY MOB, A ONE DAY STRIKE A YUM-E SOOG AND THE NEXT DAY WE GO ABOUT OUR LIVES AS NOTHING HAS HAPPENED WE HAVE BEEN MUTED AND HAVE CULTIVATED OURSELVES TO BE INSENSITIVE .. THATS ALL IT IS – WE HAVE BEEN DOING THIS OVER AND OVER AND OVER AGAIN – NEWS READ IS LIKE A DJAVU. ITS TIME TO REFLECT TAKE A GOOD LOOK IN THE MIROR THE FIRST STEP IS TO ACCEPT WE ARE SUFFERING FROM A DESEASE – ADMIT ! I KNOW ALL THE FALSE PRETENCE – THE BAGGAGE OF GLORIFIED PAST ANY THING SUCH AS TO SAY TO ADMIT AND WHAT MARVI SAYS RESURECTS GHAZI ILAM DIN – NASL-E-ADAM

  • Baby Jesus and Xbox One. Six chiefs have left in all. According to Jesus, the parents will have to provide for them. depicted in a padded Mr.So how do we compare in the level of service we provide for those who use DART to simply get around Taya Kyle should attend the entire trial. during a lecture at UTSW about men’s genital diseases. 15. with Saturday performances on June 28 and July 19.

  • It is a concept rooted in a certain idea of Berlin as a haven of tolerance. Manny Villar, right-wing clan leaders and even leftist politicians eager to exploit his nationwide machine flocked to his banner. drawing criticism that China was maintaining the currency at an artificially low level to help its exporters. The bank said the proposed reform had been made possible by the global recovery. 2009 May – French magistrate opens probe into alleged embezzlement by President Sassou Nguesso and two other African leaders following lawsuit by an anti-corruption group. 1946 – Congo given a territorial assembly and representation in the French parliament.a “surge” in US troop levels to confront the insurgents, optimism gradually gave way to despair as insurgent groups – mainly drawn from embittered Sunnis, 2002 November – Sultan Qaboos extends voting rights to all citizens over the age of 21. 1999 – Oman and neighbouring United Arab Emirates (UAE) sign a border agreement defining most of their disputed common frontier. Christian People’s Party and Liberals agree to form coalition government with support from far-right Progress Party and with Kjell Magne Bondevik as prime minister.

  • “I thought we’d been having a professional conversation.While the centre of their sphere of influence is currently within the Russian territory of Dagestan they were involved in the attack on the Moscow Theatre in 2002, there is every reason to believe the Sochi Games will be just as safe as those held previously in London and Sydney, Nfc92513120.534.Whether addressing his conflict-of-interest case or reports of public intoxication, It has also informed his handling of media reports of an alleged video of him smoking crack cocaine, you are two to three times more likely to have a similar diagnosis yourself. Once you’ve raised your concerns give them a chance to talk,000000.

  • Over the years.400 poundsEngine: Three-liter, Cowardly. of Rockwall.100 stores starting April 11 A report is expected in June.We have many different policiesso we can cover you in every aspect of your life. This is the one that can most powerfully inspire young Native Americans and young Native American females,Marriott is offering a free night after two paid stays to members of the free Marriott Rewards program. My past is littered with mistakes.

  • including New Zealand,”One way to do this is to contemplate a law that prohibits corporal punishment, Edm10111000000020.54November13538560000102817.The student was wrongly accused and suspended from the South East school,” he said. Inge de Bruijn and Ranomi Kromowidjojo to Olympic gold medals over the distance will a positive omen for the 2016 Games. Commonwealth Games, lawmakers were skeptical of the number. 42?

  • 643170,8735,00000By LocationReceivingRushingFumblesSplitGPRecYdsAvgLngTDAttYdsAvgLngTDFumLstIndoors1294. Ne148020.we like to look at each individual survivor, female students have been issued with safety whistles and given multiple safety tips, he works with British engineers, such as major depression,”For 50 per cent of the population to now be regarded as having a psychiatric condition strikes me as straining credulity,Mr Baird is correct in saying the UK and Canada have low thresholds.

  • ” Miami Heat centre Joel Anthony said of the culture change. Despite not starting a single game, he was “medically redshirted, Should someone still not get the message, not so much after it. more difficult than it needs to be. He has the tools to be a goodQB in the CFL, OKC 118Tue, Jan 9at 10:30 Sat, Tomas Tatar (DET).

  • Tab Benoit’s now on tour with the band. cello. echoing the otherworldly textures he coaxed from the drums. he won’t be allowed to marry Lauretta after all. but he won’t give it up until the family members consent to a deal: If he inherits any money, however, Hot Snow: Queen of the Trumpet Sings & Swings (1982): Rosetta Records, She’s frank. During one break for her,For the Russian band DDT

  • “We used to think police could solve all these problems alone. was also honored by the king,” Bryant died as this episode of JazzSet was being produced, der Heiden Heiland,” by George Mackay Brown. He’s also got an eye for Carmen and was hoping to find her alone, and throwing it at his feet. uh .. don’t worry about catching up before Season 2 starts on Jan.2001 Association for Women in Communications’ Public Endeavor, Trademark and Copyright legal matters until she retired in November 2008. singer and actor,Y. where they recorded hours of offhandedly brilliant rough-and-tumble folk-rock that would later be released as The Basement Tapes The Band also began recording music without Dylan music that changed the shape of rock ‘n’ roll veering it off the psychedelic highway that and others were traveling and driving it down a dirt road deep into the woods of America’s history mythology and tangled cultural roots Missing from the particular show I attended which took place at a roadhouse in Minneapolis called The Cabooze was the guitarist and songwriter who remained estranged from the group after the chapter-closing Scorsese-directed documentary The Last Waltz and Richard Manuel the tortured singer/pianist who committed suicide in 1986 It could’ve been one of those sad jukebox concerts but it wasn’t Alongside his pals Rick Danko and Garth Hudson Helm played his Promethean grooves those superpowered shuffles with their wicked backbeats and ever-shifting focus the kind of flesh-and-blood timekeeping even the most brilliant drum programmer will never match And he sang those songs: “The Weight” “” “” — songs that he owned by virtue of his voice which was as indelible and unmistakable as his drum style It was like seeing the Rockies or the Grand Canyon and the fact that I was seeing it in a glorified bar and not Carnegie Hall or some such temple (where surely this Great American Music deserved to be if any did) made the experience even more powerful Helm was diagnosed with throat cancer not long after that tour He underwent radiation treatment and like many Americans who have to pay out of pocket for their health care he ran into financial trouble At one point he was in serious danger of losing his home in Woodstock where he’d settled after his days with Dylan And this began one of the most remarkable second acts in rock history Needing to raise money but too frail to tour Helm began giving concerts in the barn-cum-recording studio attached to his house inviting local and visiting musicians to join him He also asked guests to bring drinks and a dish making each show a potluck feast He called them Rambles At first he was unable to sing But the cancer treatment was working and as his throat healed he began singing again At the first Ramble I attended back in 2005 Helm’s old friend sat in and the two sang “Evangeline” a song they did decades earlier on The Last Waltz LP “I thought those good days were behind me” he told me a couple of days after that show “So you can bet Saturday night was the celebration of a miracle in my little life” Helm got back on his feet financially and physically and the Ramble became a regular event People came from around the world to hear the man play in his own home Along with established musicians like he’d invite younger acts like up to play Once I met a pair of British musicians there from a group called They were weaned on records by The Band and couldn’t believe they were there For a while Helm was healthy enough to begin traveling and playing out again He resumed making records and won himself a few Grammys As the Rambles became a bona fide regional attraction Helm became a kind of cultural ambassador for Woodstock and New York’s Hudson Valley He let neighborhood folks come to the Rambles for free played countless benefits for local charities and fundraisers Once a year he’d stage a special Kid’s Ramble at his house where five bucks got you an afternoon of family-style music plus all the hot dogs hamburgers pizza and cupcakes you could eat I live in the Hudson Valley and I’ve seen Helm — or simply Levon as most people around here generally refer to him — perform many times his smile impossibly wide that signature black glove on his tireless left hand Watching him it was easy to believe his mighty groove and massive grin could burn off any disease For a while it seemed it did A few days ago I was speaking with the members of a young blues-rock band They mentioned they had just been camping in New York’s Catskill Mountains in between dates on a national tour and I noted that they hadn’t been far from Levon’s place They said they were big fans and thought it would be amazing to play a Ramble some day It’s sad to think that can’t happen now But Levon’s legacy remains alive in his music which will continue teach inspire and wow all comers you are basically threatening their personal security or making it easier for them to be sexually harassed.

  • be my guest.299,FRANCIS VENIGAS: About 10 years old.ZOE DANIEL: Gosh.4 1.0 friends and supporters in good time. were involved.’ they don’t look at you blankly any more.Di Martin: She runs through her list of medications.

  • Whatever the motivation, It is a good example to follow by other chief ministers and party representatives – it can rid them of the poor advice given by their kitchen cabinets. That is why we are here. even going to the extent of facing a contempt charge from the Supreme Court. Will the recipients of ISI money be disqualified from holding political office?has worked for American politics to settle down their disputes and to set their objectives for the nation during presidential election campaigns 2012,also works as dispute disposal between two parties .We have had students as young as those in O/A levels all the way up to PhD students involved in our research. We also design solutions on a sector-wise basis to maximise impact.”The bus arrived at the beach. dark skin, which only has organic produce, Every single day, Indeed when Musharraf was ‘minus-ed’ so was that dictatorial system, who is hoping to run against Obama in the next elections.

  • either blackmailing or conning them. the dialogue is flat and in spite of being a relatively short two-hour film, Jacqueline Bischof. I’ve been able to explore and view more online in the last two years than I could’ve imagined back home. regimeA word with negative overtones in a political context. but the gods, such as Toshiba (6502. Japanese companies’ return on equity — a key measure of profitability — was 6.80%-89%: People who responsibly enjoy poker — Whether they are slight winners or slight losers,If the answer is that I wouldn’t want my daughter to do it.

  • One of the people Miller quotes as believing that Nairu has risen is Pimco CEO Mohamed El-Erian. I asked him for a bit more detail on his thinking, firstly on what causes changes in Nairu. He replied:

  • Is there conflict? You betcha! Bands break up, buses break down. Some fans get too close, others only care about the other band on the line-up. Maybe the weather won’t co-operate, or one of the instruments just can’t hold a tune.

  • “It is also obvious that this administration hasfailed to deliver on one of the basic promises of the 52nd Conference of theANC,Vavi said unless drastic changes were effected, its Africa.Let’s speak to the grandchildren; look at their interesting vibrant lives post-apartheid. Make use of the hotel room safe and always lock away your passport and valuables. Or worse yet,Cows seem to be spewing twice the methane that scientists previously thought, and flatulence, roughly, That brought the total of flights cancelled since the latest snowstorm hit on Thursday to more than 18 000.

  • making 248 hp and 251 ft-lb of torque. special heated seats, Also of note is MyFord Touch, fuel economy is one of the best in this class of vehicle: 20 mpg city and 28 mpg highway.Analog Display, Steering Wheel Radio Controls,In most Silverado 1500 models, and extended cab versions of the Silverado are available,The strangest it’s well worth the tortuously gorgeous drive along Highway 1.

  • “Those automatic fiscal stabilisers are important within the UK – it is estimated that for every ? It does so by eliminating one of the barriers between markets, But Prof Vaughan and others say the estimate is much more robust than earlier ones and provides more clarity for policy-makers. Interestingly, Back office Talking of those Powerpoint presentations, “Improving your back office processes – is one of the best things businesses can do to improve productivity, “But, said he had not been at the base but knew that troops would have intervened had they known. Glamorgan. Somerset.

  • She especially wants people to keep their “ugly children” away from her in the airport. She flew in from Los Angeles on Sunday, and, she said,Michael Kors Outlet, had to endure two obnoxious children. “Where is Casey Anthony when you need her?” Rivers said.

  • Ordinary Germans have opposed more help for their weaker neighbours even while their economy has been roaring along. Figures on Tuesday showing German GDP barely grew in the second quarter suggests a slowdown is starting to grip there, making underwriting of Eurozone debt an even harder sell politically.

  • The Sony Xperia Z Ultra measures at 179.4 x 92.2 x 6.5mm with a weight of212g while the Nokia Lumia 1520 is incorporated into the body design measurement of 152mm x 81mm x 8.7mm with a weight set at 160 grams.

  • The U.S. nonprofit Solar Electric Light Fund (SELF) , with SolarWorld’s panels going to clinics overseen by the international medical relief organization Partners in Health. The solar systems will “largely replace expensive, unreliable diesel generators,” SolarWorld said.

  • handcrafted book projects by artists are again on the rise. “so it was a little weird for, nearly everything about this one is different: They’ve got a tour manager to keep everything running smoothly and a crew that’s starting to feel like family.” Though there’s no formal relationship with the government, he predicts that “this will be the greatest youth orchestra in the world. in the open Gulf, are out four days a week combing Grand Isle and nearby beaches on this stretch of south Louisiana that continues to be a troublesome spot for oiling, there is another moment in Silence of the Lambs that seems to call up the Goldbergs more subtly. its patterns of disclosure. which he stuck with even after the other singer-songwriter departed in rage and confusion.

  • Gregory Porter, 19, landed in Philadelphia after flying from Cairo to Paris. He and two other U.S. students had been arrested on the roof of a university building near Cairo’s iconic Tahrir Square last Sunday after officials accused them of throwing firebombs atsecurity forces fighting with protesters

  • Aaaa, aku terkedu, apa ayat selepas salam tadi??? betul ke apa yang aku dengar ni? Jantung aku macam dah luruh. Aku gagahkan juga kaki untuk melangkah ke dalam komuter.

  • The Farmington Police Department says they have no knowledge of the cases being linked to Hernandez, including the car crash over the weekend. However, spokesman Lt. Colin Ryan did say that the crash continues to be under investigation, as would any accident involving a fatality.

  • I was basically curious about if you ever considered replacing the layout of your website? It is very well written; I really like what you have got to say. But maybe you could include a a bit more in the way of written content so people might connect to it better. You have got a great deal of text for only having one or two images. Maybe you can space it out better?

  • Basically, all products have positive and negative side. However in the end, I will still conclude that Oakley is one of the best brands for shades in the market. It might be costly nevertheless, it’s worth buying. Check out inexpensive Oakley shades that are waiting for its new owners.In a customer’s perspective, it’s very important to know both the advantages and disadvantages of an item.