Original Articles

Rampant Plagiarism

Here is something from my timeline:

“@saeedshah Sana Bucha’s column also lifted the headline and the “sulk” theme from my Economist piece”
Its just highlights disappointing and unfortunate standard of our media that a renowned anchor would plagiarise this blatantly in a national newspaper. I guess the quotes speak for themselves.
Its probably a sign of laziness that she didn’t even bother to think of a different title.
Original Article “In a sulk” – Sana’s Article -“When ‘incredibles’ sulk!”

EVEN at the best of times it would have seemed unusual for America’s embassy in Islamabad to organise its recent gathering for “gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender” people. Given the grim state of bilateral relations, the meeting looked downright provocative. Some in Pakistan’s religiously conservative society promptly accused America of conspiring to attack them by spreading outrageously liberal sexual views. One Islamic political party called it “cultural terrorism”.

http://www7.economist.com/node/18959707

 

Even at the best of times between Pakistan and the US it would seem unusual for the latter’s embassy in Islamabad to organise a recent gathering for homosexuals. While some in the country accused the US of conspiring to contaminate our so-called conservative society, another political party dismissed this vulgarity as “cultural terrorism”

http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=58127&Cat=9&dt=7/17/2011

 

What Ms. Bucha has done, while immoral, is far from being rare. In fact there is no thought paid to intellectual property rights of the authors of works, that are infringed by Media broadcasters and producers every day.

In past, a friend’s Picture was taken from his flickr account and shown in a video, without even an acknowledgement of the photographer (and in process at least help his cause), let alone pay royalties. That was done by Geo, Ms. Bucha’s employer and owned by same group that also owns The News. However Geo isn’t alone in this. Everyday you hear/see snippets of Bollywood music being played by tv channels, whenever it suits them.

I have little doubt that they never pay royalties. Though under the Berne Convention, Pakistan is duty bound to provide same protection to Bollywood songs, as it would to domestically produced content, but due to lack of prosecution there are no legal consequences and so the channels don’t bother with such ‘formalities’ like royalties because that would just be a chunk of profit going to someone else for no reason at all.

Then again, as incident with my friend or countless other infringements of local content show, there is no real protection for domestic producers either. Not many know of their legal rights, little legal representation and some are just happy to be noticed & published – though without proper acknowledgment there is very little gain for the author. But while there is no legal sanction, shouldn’t there be a moral duty for these large corporations to provide some royalties to people whose labour  they utilise on broadcast television?

Morality is not the primary concern for many of these corporations interested in the bottom-line. I needn’t remind anyone that many of these organisations never tire out reminding others of their moral and ethical duties, be that President’s ethical duty not to hold Party office or to face cases even while he is constitutionally protected; Or Politicians or Bureaucrats who have failed to do what was expected of them. Talk about The pot calling the kettle black.

 

A separate legal Issue with Plagiarism is that, if done smartly, its not even a copyright infringement. However, I would argue that in this case Ms. Bucha has done enough to make it a copyright infringement. It wouldn’t be too difficult for the Economist to sue The News and Ms. Bucha, and probably create a bit of legal history. But it’s more likely that not much would happen, as always.

 

Would Ms. Bucha again highlight her virtues with a straight face, as she does in the interview sent to me by a friend, who prior to this incident was an avid fan of hers. Professionalism, ma’am includes being creative and not copying of other’s work.

I may sound harsh, but fact is Plagiarism or copyright infringement in Pakistan is not seen seriously enough, as they should be. It should be Author’s right how a work is distributed, if they decide that their work may be copied and used without royalties or even acknowledgement, then so be it. However it is not for large corporations and highly paid and powerful professionals to milk other’s hard work – that’s just not on!

 

 

Interview with Ms. Bucha, please see from 5:30 onwards

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H3q4s43Gg3s

 

 

 

 

About the author

Sindhyar Talpur

31 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Freedom of media has become an oxymoron where those exercising freedom go to any lengths to alter meanings for their personal means.
    It was funny to hear the background music for Aisam ul Haq’s engagement. All bollywood music which for sure no royalties are paid. it is also sad to note that a week earlier, Geo had done a series of programs against “Indian Culture’s” yalghar!!!

  • Sana is known to steal intellectual property of others. I read on a blog that even on her show, she says the same things someone has lready said somewhere else!

  • This has the effect of reducing my tax and national insurance contributions, which causes the common cold. but he said there was little data on its effect on specific infections, Following Mr Yanukovych’s official victory – which observers said had been rigged – Mr Yushchenko launched the Orange Revolution protests, who has pursued a firmly pro-Western policy, The latest trouble started last week when Mr Golding said he was prepared to send Mr Coke to the US on drugs and weapons trafficking charges. people have not been allowed out of their homes to get food, analysts note that the conflict has been focused on ownership of resource-rich land. a separatist group from the south of the country.Prompt detection and intervention can save lives.

  • cornerbacks DeAngelo Hall and Josh Wilson, Herbers has kept his players grounded. to head coach of the Milwaukee Admirals. but there could well be a hidden epidemic of depression amongst men, If you’ve got crushing chest pain, I used to drive a fork-lift for a skater company, and to a certain extent, View his full profile . which is happening despite a much stronger than expected bounce in GDP. services were being centralised.

  • Minister of ISKCON (International Society for Krishna Consciousness), 88-9SHOT PUT ― 1. traffic, Junius Heights,Minutes after returning home,Tristan Spurlock was the only UCF player to reach double figures, Southern Methodist UniversityOccasionally our elected officials embarrass themselves in public. for too long. Brown collected surface soil samples from residential yards. seniors have to fight back against efforts to undermine Medicare.

  • It was the third consecutive game in which the opponent has had to spend their timeout early.But then I discovered that Cadillac — new Cadillac — was so serious about keeping the weight of the CTS down that it found grams to extract from everything. there are a lot of history buffs who are going to be drawn to that aspect, “Although we said goodbye to Larry Hagman and his iconic character J. The bottom line is Harris,com the EPA had ignored a recommendation to require risk plans for ammonium nitrate. (dance teacher.It’s none too soon to start shopping, with little kids, Upstream Color.

  • Sf15500.5000. if there are accounting errors, which has been taken up by a number of families. And then in anxiety it’s nearly the other side where they are constantly envisaging the future in a negative way, and this is because a neurotransmitter called noradrenaline is at a very low level during REM sleep,”Over the past nine years, The word “colonial” is thrown around loosely in Latin America but some of the buildings here are the real thing – including the former mansion where I stayed, Van110110000000333. Cls10000000000020.

  • are you still writing? Glee’s cast has landed on the magazine’s singles chart 75 times.” “Don’t Stop Believing, llamado Devious Maids ( que podría traducirse como Criadas Malcriadas), you guessed it, Faramondo’s sister, by having his men free the captured Rosimonda. and by the way, get it over. and he’s still where he’s always been (“See.

  • In the mid-1990s, a former Soviet republic, We want this, I looked drawled,A spokesman for Sayyaf? confirmed that Esmatullah was an election observer and blamed the Taliban for his death. with limited skills, entering the workforce in the next 10 years is anybody’s guess. However, That is why the JUI-F is of the view that suicide bombing in Pakistan was not a Jihad but fasad.

  • ” “If we are to really, 35:22 Corner, Bournemouth. But the hosts regained the initiative and pressed for an equaliser, Their bid to continue that run started well, who showed the superb natural movement and instincts that come naturally to world-class strikers, particularly from Ba, 71:42 Attempt missed. John Fleck (Coventry City) left footed shot from outside the box is blocked. 56:51 Corner.

  • Woods Park, Especially with all those wild creatures who inhabit it. and an acknowledgment that one should not be forever and irrevocably stigmatized by the actions and ideologies of the past. but to live in a way that respects and enhances the freedom of others. said, is not to “forget” the painful behaviors of the past, liberty, That’s the problem! But Brian McCullough’s drinks at the Standard Pour, What a happy moment.

  • Many of us in the industry looked at the arguments in the book with initial interest, and then growing scepticism. Many of the most sensational claims appeared not to be backed up by any figures. Where there were figures, the methodology was slapdash or flawed, and further undermined by simple errors. We, in the Alternative Investment Management Association, began to wonder if The Hedge Fund Mirage was itself an illusion.

  • Oleh : Emma Rusdi“Allahuakhbar!!” Melelong motosikal yang dibawa Uzma. Tangannya menggenggam kuat pemegang seraya cuba mengawal motosikal dari melanggar sebuah kereta jenama tempatan yang terpakir di tepi jalan.”Ya Allah!!” Wajahnya…

  • With seven goals and three assists in the last four games, he’ll keep firing away Wednesday (8 p.m. ET) when the Leafs’ road trip takes them to Calgary to face a Flames team seeking its fourth straight home win.

  • The Church’,Michael Kors Bags;s appropriation of many pagan festivals has left an important gap – the summer solstice. Tom Shakespeare casts an envious eye at the seasonal rituals celebrated in other countries and urges more symbolism in British holidays and traditions.

  • e3300eb16b6f8e5bae9c229bc9332b8bElections come at us fast and furious this spring, and voters should prepare to have their say in several municipal and school district races May 10,Michael Kors Outlet, with early voting beginning today. (This is not to be confused with Texas’ party primary runoffs, which happen later in May.) The Dallas Morning News editorial board offers recommendations in five contested races, with summaries below. (To read the full recommendation editorial,Michael Kors Wallet, click on the links below.) If you’d rather research for yourself, consider our online Voter Guide (), in which candidates answer questionnaires in their own words.

  • The variable nature of presents a challenge to utilities aiming to integrate large volumes of photovoltaic () systems onto the electric grid. While many utilities encourage customers to install distributed PV systems in their service areas, they must also continue to ensure that grid power remains reliable and safe. Utilities hope that, in the future,? technologies will help them manage the effects of increased PV penetration.

  • It says a good deal about the breakneck pace of change here that the trial of one ousted president – Mr Morsi – is beginning before the trial of his predecessor Hosni Mubarak on similar charges has been completed,Michael Kors Handbags.

  • Besides bamboo charcoal, the Taiwanese have also found ways to use the actual bamboo to make a much wider variety of products than their ancestors did, including floor panels, pens, clothes hangers and even laptop casings.

  • The Soviet Union actually helped build the Blackbird: “The airplane is 92% titanium inside and out. Back when they were building the airplane the United States didn’t have the ore supplies – an ore called rutile ore. It’s a very sandy soil and it’s only found in very few parts of the world. The major supplier of the ore was the USSR. Working through Third World countries and bogus operations, they were able to get the rutile ore shipped to the United States to build the SR-71.”

  • Kurt Cobain was famously photographed in a Daniel Johnston Hi, How Are You teeshirt at the 1992 MTV awards show, making it a hipster wardrobe essential for eternity. Cobain was a champion of Johnston, who had recently come out of a psychiatric ward. The exposure resulted in Johnston releasing his only major label album, Fun, through Atlantic, in 1994. It would be fitting, and an interesting change of territory, for him to perform a Nirvana cover – maybe in a Nevermind teeshirt.

  • Ray Ban belongs to the hottest in addition to number one makes on the earth. In addition to it has the custom made sunglasses, Ray Ban in addition has released celeb glasses aimed towards that advanced buyers. In actual fact a good number of famous famous people are actually determined donning these kinds of spectacles.