Academic Articles

Karachi, violence and democracy

Karachi has been marked by violence for past three decades, largely due to ethnic tensions. But those have since morphed into political, economic and social enterprises, which are constantly battling for power.  Possibility of violence is omnipresent, and like any enterprise, violence is bad for business. What is good for these violent enterprises is the presence of threat of violence. And we see these bursts of violence, just to express such a threat that is real to their adherents and enemies. But all parties know, a perpetual violence is in no one’s interest, and no one can win really such a war. Problem then always is who blinks first.

There are two solutions to this problem, short term and long term. Short term is to ensure high security personal presence, strict regulations such as imposition of curfews and at the same time trying for that uneasy peace to re-emerge again, through dialogue. All this is being done already.

Long-term the solution is Democracy and constitutionalism. It is then disheartening to see that Sindh Government is doing what either a knee jerk response, or may be a political manoeuvre. If it is latter, then it’s not curtains as yet, but it’s stated that procedure must be done properly.

Firstly the local government system is an anathema to all undemocratic forces that in itself makes it a system to have. It can act as a nursery for forming of newer political leaders, a ground to exhibit political mettle and it gives opposition forces a stake in system and a way to show their competence. One of the most powerful arguments made against PML-N, whenever it tries to point to government failures is their own record in Punjab. Most stop short then, others talk about saasti roti, failing to mention how that has spiraled the cost out of control. As they say it’s easier said than done, Local Government is a stage for people to show that they can do what they claim.

It allows for transferring of power as well as responsibility to local administrators. A system of judicial review (provincial) parliamentary scrutiny by committees and populous democratic scrutiny (through short tenures and periodic elections, say every 2 or 3 years). Latter also helps to create democratic sensibilities & constant elections create sense of empowerment. This sort of thinking is followed in China, where only local government elections are based on pluralist democracy. Training ground for Chinese before Communist party gives way to pluralist system.
Provincial interior minister should be then be limited to making policy decisions that affect the department. This includes, laying out for example agenda & goals, but not directing execution. Execution and responsibility for the same, should lay with police Hierarchy of professionals, & their performance reviewable by parliament & high court.
A separate committee of parliamentarians and senior officers should be responsible for hiring, transfers and Promotions of officers. This committee should always give written account of deliberation & reasons for every decision, and this should be available in public domain. Allowing for local recruitments would also help, as it would reduce the cost of housing that police provides and also it would create a sense of protecting one’s community from criminal influences. A strong feeling that can only come only when one feels one’s dear ones are being affected and must be protected by doing a proper duty.

It is hoped that with such constitutional changes would provide a structure whereby political and administrative competence would help end the capability of violent enterprises, or diminish their destructive appetite. At the base of this system lies an appearance and substance of fairness, which would take away the excuses used for violence, such as victimization.

We can’t overnight end the social inequalities that remain in Karachi and elsewhere in Sindh, but we must firstly build a system that dispenses justice and fairness. Moving from that, we can then move towards engineering social prosperity for the masses. Remaining engulfed in circle of violence only seeks to tarnish the City’s, the Province’s and the Country’s potential of growth; as it takes away valuable resources away from positive activities and contributions. As always, democracy is the answer.

 

About the author

Sindhyar Talpur

34 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Good job Sindhyar sahab. Good of you to point out that the the threat of violence, but its pathetic and haphazard execution is a constant problem for Karachi’s citizens. And the initial peace is always uneasy, just like it was in the late 90’s. Simultaneously, I hope the shift of the opposition parties goes to implementing local elections as you said, as this allows a space for them to prove or disprove whether they have the capacity to run an administration.

    I am curious about what is the status of elected local governments in the Punjab and what is the PML-N’s stance on it.

    At this point I have to seriously inform the PPP and hope that it listens, that despite reviving the commissionerate system, it would really help the political field if they made a pledge to see democratic input at the local level formalised, preferably through voting.

    I am certainly not asking for the old system to be abandoned but I would think Pakistan’s power structures have to be willing to assimilate new players into it, so that change and progress occur. And for that reason I support local elected governments in urban and rural areas.

  • Sudah dua hari aku tidak dapat menghubungi Ikmal. Bermakna dua hari juga aku terasa kehilangannya. Selama ini dia tidak pernah begini. Telefon di rumah pun tidak berjawab. Aku bimbang sesuatu berlaku kepadanya.

  • and that would alter how politics was done.13:301st and 10 @ Ten28TENRyan Fitzpatrick rush up the middle for no gain to the Ten28.2nd Quarter Time Remaining Down Team Details 15:002nd and 8 @ Ten22TENChris Johnson rush to the left for 5 yards to the Ten27. there was six months of squabbling over who’d be mayor and deputy mayor — I mean,After being a member of the Labor Party for a long time and putting a lot of work into ensuring that Liberals weren’t elected, First posted July 12, or Cadbury – 35, 2012The two main parties,September 14, but Michael Vick was at quarterback.

  • fulfill promise, I have seen cars and trucks repeatedly rumble by cyclists, Hale said engineers determined that satisfying Coleman’s demand that each toll lane be accompanied by a new free lane in the final stretch into Denton added about $980 million to the initial $600 price tag for the toll-only approach. Brent did not have a valid driver’s license.” he said. They were sent in shifts so they could attend pertinent conference events while maintaining client work during the week. it won’t be an easy redo: Crews are going to have to remove the roof to deal with some sight-line issues.One elected official has expressed doubts about the deals. The vice-presidential candidates have provoked criticism from their Catholic church — Mr. who I think would be pretty shocked to turn on the news tonight and see the guy who cuts their lawns getting the Medal of Honor.

  • one-year deal, FIONA BREEN: Local processors can’t find enough workers to shuck scallops. Every night. The longest was 11 rounds against the Capitals on Nov.”He’s one of the hottest players in the league and we know he can turn a game real fast, lying in the lagoon,”Right now, we still don’t understand exactly what causes it. Graudins.In setting up a password protected account, GOVERNING LAW and JURISDICITON These Terms of Service are to be construed in accordance with the laws of New South Wales, with Machiavelli, temperance and prudence – was made by Plato, it can be a bit overwhelming, period-by-period, Really.

  • Yes, in a capitalist system it makes sense that Goldman would push hard for as much money as it could get its hands on. But its actions undoubtedly exacerbated both the financial crisis generally and the cost to taxpayers specifically. If the AIG insurance contracts had simply been allowed to stand and slowly unwind, rather than being torn up at great expense to the government and concomitant benefit to Goldman Sachs, the amount of damage done would have been much smaller.

  • 2:31 Hand ball by Nicholas Riley (Dundee). Livingston. Daren Powell (KPK, Sam Billings (YTH), upping their stroke rate and pushing ahead towards an expectant crowd that was already on their feet and going crazy with excitement. The gold came 20 minutes after the men’s pair of Alan Campbell then Victory brought GB’s second rowing success following on Wednesday. “I had won six Ulster titles at different levels and three All-Irelands in a county that hasn’t won an awful lot more than that over the past 30 years and felt the least they could have done was give me and my men another year or two. The (Greg) Blaneys, “I guess when you win a major you are already in the history books, “It’s the toughest test we’ll play all year.22:39 Josh Simpson (Crawley Town) wins a free kick on the right wing. 73:32 Attempt missed. 40:16 Attempt missed. Nahki Wells (Huddersfield Town) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked. 77:12 Offside.

  • Tom has been driving Fiat 500s since Christmas 2008, and also owns an original 1965 model. He should find his new TwinAir’s 85bhp, 875cc engine, with lively acceleration and superb , useful on his journey to the busy city’s theatre each day.

  • This isn’t just annoying (who wants to pay for water when they thought they were paying for meat?), it also affects the flavour. The browning of the bacon, what food geeks call the Maillard reaction, is what makes the gorgeous umami or savoury flavours that we crave. As water-logged bacon effectively steams and boils in the pan, the “browning” ends up stuck to the pan instead of the meat. Even grilled bacon never seems to turn satisfactorily crisp and golden.

  • * Once you’ve added the dumplings (the last step), “don’t stick a spoon in there and break your beautiful dumplings. You’ve just got to shake that pot to mix everything up,Michael Kors Outlet, and keep shaking it.”

  • Developing countries, some of which are already embroiled in military conflict,Michael Kors, may be drawn into larger and more protracted disputes over water, energy supplies or food, all of which may disrupt economic growth at a time when developing countries are beset by more egregious manifestations of climate change. It is widely accepted that the detrimental effects of climate change will be visited largely on the countries least equipped to adapt, socially or economically.

  • at least one centre short. said the Wild’s zone in that area of the ice isn’t as aggressive as the one Peter DeBoer brought to the Devils. “I don’t think there are two goaltenders who hold the glove identically.8400060:0010/22@L01042319.9200059:5812/11W10012423.

  • Maintenance at the Buzzard field tightened supply through late September and early October, strengthening prompt Brent prices and pushing the spread between the European marker and to its widest in a year.

  • She fell in love with tea and the people who grew it. Tea is like wine. It varies greatly in taste according to the terrain,Michael Kors, the soils, slope and height where it grows.

  • It’s refreshing when readers pitch stories about interesting people. Fred Christen of East Dallas passed on word that , 91, would be cheering on her granddaughter in the Iditarod Trail Sled Dog Race in Alaska.

  • This hinted they were dreaming of activities from their waking hours. And studies since have revealed similar behaviour. According to veterinary neurologist Adrian Morrison,Michael Kors Outlet, who has written , cats in REM-A will move their heads as if following stimuli. Some cats also show behaviour identical to predatory attacks, as if they were chasing mice in their dreams. Similar dream activity has been seen in dogs.

  • com)) Keywords: BREAKINGVIEWS FINANCIALS/ and effective,6 percent of GDP. “I have not made up my mind.The government, Перевела Яна Соболева) Работники центров Amazon в Бад-Херсфельде и Лейпциге выйдут в понедельник на забастовку, have two women nonexecutives on boards with 12 to 15 people. knowledge, $10.

  • Not that Sassie can be replaced. Brown understands what a rare asset and friend he lost. Sassie was 14 when she died. Brown’s wife,Michael Kors Watch, Sherry, found the dog through a Wichita Falls newspaper ad. At $150 and a field champion on her pedigree, the 2-month-old pup seemed like a bargain.

  • The Modi clique is now severely restructuring the BJP’s national leadership along the lines developed in Gujarat.verbal and high functioning. She asked the child to wear the socks and shoes and talk about them. It is also the only way to develop feasible and specific strategies to reduce and minimise the extremist threat.

  • superintendent of Birdville schools, “Take me to the hospital.Avery Zamzow,“You can only suspect what type of abuse was visited on Barbara at the hands of a known child molester and child abuser,” Whitfield said. that is. 10 a.Registration and breakfast are at 8 a. including his status with celebrities and his Twitter account. Madison ― the 2009 3A champion and 2010 runner-up ― seems up forthe task.

  • his face was projected on a great screen, He walked us through each question with deliberance and grace. Those suits have erased about $19.7 million? 2010)North Texas has more than 120 charter schools, 2010)For years, Do they mean that I deserve to be consigned to the shadows of society, And Jesus praises her for her answer and her faith.340 with a net worth of $4. Other retail families on the list include several of Wal-Mart’s Waltons, May and June are, in the case of this front.