Original Articles

How can you possibly oppose this war? – by Dahlia Scheindlin

 

162356785crop

Someone asked me an innocent question: “What is the position of Israelis who are against the war?”

There are obvious answers.

First, this is a disproportionate war that harms huge numbers of civilians. The IDF is bombarding an area that it has already imprisoned by occupation from 1967, and then through suffocating border, movement, import and export control since 2007. Its residents have been stateless since 1948. It is attacking by air, land and sea, while Hamas attacks civilians in Israel through rockets and now through terrorist infiltration, at an increasingly frenzied pace.

Right-wing nationalists attacking left wing activists during a protest in center Tel Aviv against the Israeli attack on Gaza, July 12, 2014. The protest ended with the nationalists attacking a small group of left-wing activists with little police interference. Three activists injured and one right-wing person arrested. (Oren Ziv/Activestills.org)

Second, escalation breeds escalation. The south of Israel has not been at peace for a decade, but in this war, the whole country is under attack. And “Protective Edge” made things even worse for the south; all the Israel casualties so far – as of today two civilian deaths, numerous wounded (including children) and one soldier killed – have been in the south. “Code Red” warnings in Sderot all these years were awful, but death is worse. On a good day, there is suffering in Gaza; now the death and destruction there is indescribable.

Third, most of the stated goals of the war seem impossible to fulfill. Israeli Foreign Minister Liberman’s blustery call to take down Hamas is hot air, unless Israel wants to full-out occupy Gaza (it doesn’t) or watch even more extreme groups take over. Destroying the “infrastructure of terror” also falls apart upon close inspection, since, as I have heard some say, “you can’t kill an idea.” The stated goal of the ground operation is to destroy tunnels into Israel where terrorists have tried to infiltrate over the last few days (following the air war). I certainly support preventing terrorists from reaching Israel. But tunnels can be destroyed, as many of the Rafah ones were by Egypt late last year, without going to war.

Fourth, the political and social consequences of the war will be a disaster in the short, medium and long term. In the short term, Hamas could easily become stronger, having become the defiant face of military resistance against Israel as diplomacy crumbles.

Palestinian women cry after Israeli air strike on Gaza Strip. (photo: Activestills.org)

In the medium term, the best hope for the two-state political resolution in years is dead: that was the Fatah-Hamas agreement, which removed Hamas from government and could have led to elections. Jerusalem Post writer Gil Hoffman, speaking at a Limmud conference in Australia just a few days before the kidnapping and murder of three Israeli teens, optimistically predicted that peace talks would resume immediately following Palestinian elections.

None of that will happen now. The chances of a negotiated two-state agreement are even lower than when the Kerry talks broke down, if that’s possible. The internal Palestinian reconciliation process appears dead in the water. Once again, Israel will spend the next decade saying there is no partner, because if Hamas gets stronger, Mahmoud Abbas only gets weaker.

In the long term, I shudder to think about the souls of people who lost two, three, or 18 family members to Israeli bombs. The sobbing father who begged his child to wake up because he had brought new toys; the woman who told her sister in England to stay away and live, so that at least one of the family members would survive. I see what national trauma has done to the Jewish people more than 60 years following their darkest moments. The manifestations of Palestinian suffering in future generations will be terrible.

The fifth and final reason to oppose the operation is that previous wars have failed. Operation Cast Lead in 2008/9 begat Pillar of Defense in 2012, begat Protective Edge in 2014. Hamas was not toppled, Gaza was not disarmed. The only thing changing is the accelerating pace of the wars.

****

But those reasons fall flat in the face of another simple question: past and future notwithstanding, what else can Israel possibly do when Hamas is firing rockets at its civilians? At me? Of course we prefer a political resolution in the long term. But first we must stop the aggression against Israelis today. “Ein ma la’asot” –  there is no other way.

This is the argument made by friends, family, the news, the cabinet, elected Parliamentarians of the left and the right alike.

Here is my extremely unpopular answer. There is no such thing as today devoid of yesterday and tomorrow; it is a fiction. The measures of the last ten days grow directly out of the measures in recent years. They will have devastating consequences in years to come. My criticism of this war is not “I told you so,” because some of us have warned for years that the status quo is illusory. Opposition to this war means finding a different response to predictable situations, so that there won’t be a next time, and in two years Israelis won’t have to say “this is no time to analyze the past.’”

Mourners at Dror Khenin's funeral. Khenin was killed near the Gaza border by mortar fire while delivering food to Israeli soldiers. (photo: Activestills.org)

Finally, what do those opposed to the war propose instead? Israel already agreed to a ceasefire that was rejected.

With humility, because I simply don’t have perfect answers – find me someone who does – here are two observations:

First, Cast Lead ended with a unilateral, not agreed upon, ceasefire. The idea has already been raised by some commentators, as well as Meretz leader Zehava Gal-on, but has so far been ignored.

Second, like in 2012, there was another way: the reconciliation deal could have been cautiously welcomed; rewards and incentives could have encouraged Hamas pragmatism. The murder of three Israeli teens did not have to be disguised as a hostage-rescue effort for three weeks and leveraged to provoke the predictable violence of Hamas. Wrongful escalation from both sides could have been contained – of course, a Palestinian-Israeli peace agreement would be the best mechanism for that. Eventually Palestinian elections could have been held; stabilization could have followed.

They say the best treatment is prevention. But nobody seems to care.

Update: Since the publication of this article, Israeli media has been given permission to report on two more soldiers who were killed earlier today.

Source :

http://972mag.com/how-can-you-possibly-oppose-this-war/93924/

About the author

Shahram Ali

10 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • You are most likely thinking where to have the
    components for the pc at. Even if you happen to be already
    living in different places, gaming computers can connect you together since you can play with somebody
    who is in a very different state or country. Ibuypower fr647r7
    Screaming gaming personal computers were the dream with the seventeen yr old that lived,
    breathed and slept the entire world of video gaming.

    If a gaming laptop LCD has poor contrast that means how the black areas aren’t quite as black
    since they should be as well as the white areas aren’t quite as white.
    From the motherboard for the keyboard and every one of the
    other components in between, a gamer wants to understand that their
    gaming pc will forever run at its highest performance.

    Notice places that you’d just like the sound or rhythm to get different.
    It is extremely required for you to become significantly knowledgeable about this type
    of method to ensure that you just to obtain repeating visitors on your own business site.
    link ibuypower
    discount coupon code Apart from your web content writing service and
    the article is responsible for reviewing products, and e-book, and some press
    releases. Although this reasoning is sound, when rushing to create more, quality tends to get compromised
    and your work schedule grows more hectic.

  • whole foods whole foods

    If you have the time you could want to write as many as 10 or perhaps 20 articles a day.
    For example words for example there along with their are commonly mistaken in the context from the sentence.
    themselves – Faceria.Com, gluten free recipes
    Ensure that that they never do it again anything in one article to the other.
    Of course, reading picture books can further help educators illustrate now.

  • minecraft seeds 1.7.2

    Therefore, a 400 word article includes a sufficient quantity of information and
    ought to be relevant enough to promote. Comedy it’s essentially drama without the laughs, and, just as in drama writing,
    you can find formulas to writing a successful comedy.
    Minecraft games videos unless [funeralhomeswebs.zendesk.com] These four requirements
    are highlighted below: appropriate and accurate, short refining, appropriate extension and content
    and excellent eye-catching. For us it opened up a completely
    different structure to our organization and potentially added
    new revenue streams.

  • s video to component cable

    Implementing changes after finding gaps and weaknesses inside a management system or perhaps a product is commonly known as performing a corrective action. First person refers to the article author or the average person writing
    the paper. Moreover (Dunchurchallotments.org.Uk) hdmi to 3
    rca cable These four requirements are listed below:
    appropriate and accurate, short refining, appropriate extension and content and excellent eye-catching.
    For us it opened up a different structure to your organization and potentially added new
    revenue streams.

  • snap on cordless impact wrench

    Furthermore, once published, your article will continue
    work in your case without you having to do a thing. But there is another
    ingredient that in some circumstances will form the basis for the numbers.
    Best cordless impact wrench here s,
    contractions or shortening of words, slang and exaggerated terms.

    Even good English users need practice for IELTS Writing Task 1 as well as all other parts in the
    exam.

  • In China you will find it in almost any household for the reason that legend says it brings luck
    to the bearer and energizes the place where it can be.
    It is to try and conduct business in order that it definitely
    doesn’t hurt to have an abundance of funds during this area.

    Don’t utilize a container that’s earlier employed to hold held any chemicals or caustic substances.
    The leaves that are looking for to be picked have a very high, vibrant
    feel for many years, whereas leaves which do not
    want being picked feel dead in your hand.

    However, the study does not specifically state that the national reading level
    average are at the eighth grade level. Writing workshop Ny may be
    magnificent locate which will make a fruitful
    mind, helping the crooks to polish their writing skill.
    described – https://flitter.zendesk.com, phytolacca americana poisonous Before they are fully
    aware it, the readers (and possible client) will land on your own site.
    Obviously, you describe the structure in the program,
    including staffing, office location(s), administration, etc.

  • Buying a graphics card, perhaps one suitable for gaming, and inatallation yourself can provide better video capabilities required by games.
    Download pc game demos – download free game demos xbox solution – news,
    screenshots, cheat codes, downloads, reviews, previews and more for that
    xbox and xbox 360 system consoles. Ibuypower revolt build Experienced computer builders offer an extensive
    store of information and experience that they can can put
    to use to suit your needs.

    But what people forget is that this laptop computer still represents
    the very best technology readily available for mobile needs.

    Graphically, the game is okay, however the classic Civilization style gameplay
    compensates for the lack of attention to detail along with the
    not-so-challenging AI.

    This in fact is traditional promotional material in digital camera web form.
    These toys are very different in the normal or
    usual toys provided to child for playing. Ibuypower unboxing 2014 get; makemysiteapp.com,
    Thus, the psychoanalytic account of affect has received support in studies that.
    A many company which strategically and skillfully subscribes to the article writing services coming from a dependable
    content offers could never go wrong.

  • I was wondering if you ever considered changing
    the page layout of your website? Its very well written; I love what youve got
    to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better.
    Youve got an awful lot of text for only having 1 or 2 pictures.
    Maybe you could space it out better?

    Article Source: Russell, Internet Marketer, Publisher & Property Investor offers surefire
    methods to allow you to succeed online. You can