Featured Original Articles

Manaqabat “Ali ke Saath Hay Zahra ki Shaadi” exploited by Mubashir Luqman: agenda promote blasphemy law & war with Geo

FINAL All Political Talk Shows of Pakistan TV Channels Geo Samaa Dunya ARY News Aaj Express NewsEditor’s note: This is a timely article. Sunni and Shia lovers of Ali a.s. and Fatimeh a.s. should ask themselves a simple question before becoming a tool for Mubashir Luqman’s war against Geo and his deputization by Mullah Lidhanvi to promote wider application of blasphemy laws.
Does Mubashir Luqman love Ali a.s. and Fatimeh a.s. more than you and more than his money or ratings?

We all agree Geo is terrible and entire media is extremely corrupt. Shia and Sunnis Brelvi should see through this trap of the Takfiri Deobandi establishment and not become a party to frivolous and nonsensical accusations of blasphemy. The ultimate end of the way blasphemy laws are being applied in Pakistan is simply to crush minorities, diversity and free speech.

LUBP is hopeful that the moderate and impartial voices will come forward and reform Pakistani media. There is plenty of good talented people in Pakistan who should replace old puppets with agendas.

 

Don’t be fooled don’t become a tool.

 

A blog on the whole Geo “Blasphemy” issue re Veena Malik from the perspective of being a Shia. I dont endorse Geo nor ARY, but I feel we need to stop playing infidel infidel and blasphemy blasphemy as a nation

Much Ado About Nothing

Perhaps social media is not the sole creator behind popular opinion but it definitely does reflect it.The current hue and cry is about Geo’s Morning Show Utho Jaago Pakistan. My timeline flooded with accusations of blasphemy the cries getting louder and more ferocious with every person; curiosity peeked  and I decided to watch the video.
Here is what I saw; the Manaqabat “Ali ke Saath Hay Zahra ki Shaadi” was played as a Qawali during Veena Malik’s wedding rasms.
I re-watched it to make sure I hadn’t missed anything.I kept waiting for the commotion to fit the crime.However there was none. I admit some rasms could have been held off as the timing with the verses weren’t befitting; however it was hardly a synchronized effort.Nor was it orchestrated to belittle. At most it could be construed as distasteful- that is the maximum extent of the penalty.If we were to levy penalties for distaste; please levy one upon the multi colored lights flickering  throughout.
Coming to the video, here is why as a Shia the video fails to fit the criteria of “Blasphemous” :
1) It is a popular manqabat which is sung at almost all Shia and Sunni Brelvi weddings I’ve attended at one point or another, during the Milad, Nikkah, or even Shaadi.
2) Nobody with a single functioning brain cell thinks it is a re-enactment and that the couple is “posing” to be Bibi Fatimah (s) or Hazrat Ali.
3) The manqabat is recited as an amalgam of spiritual sentiments and blessings in wedding celebrations.
4)Those carrying out the Rasms were doing it in the spirit of celebrations and not maliciously.If intent counted for anything in our dear court of law this would be point number one on the list.
I question the reason the bar of Faith in our country is so deeply integrated with accusations of Infidel and Blasphemy? Can we Muslims not link our identities to the actual attributes of those we hysterically claim to love? Is the patience of the Holy Prophet (s) the courage Bibi Fatimeh (s.a) and kindness of Hazrat Ali (a.s) all for speeches? Is it because we find less work and struggle in being a follower of sensationalist fundamentalism than in practical actions (myself included) that we voluntarily fall prey to the same disease time after time?
I fail to understand why as a nation we seem to be hell bent upon inviting global mockery; first by booking a 9 month old baby with attempted murder, then by charging Blasphemy upon 68 lawyers because the person happened to have the same name as a Caliph.Before the world assumes my sect as the reason for bias clouding my judgement, let me clarify; regardless of the name, even if it was Ali or Husain I would’ve still been astounded at the integrity of the authority making  such ludicrous charges. Humans are the supreme creation (ashraful makhlookat) because of our unique mental faculty, the ability to think.The mere possession  of the faculty doesn’t warrant supremacy in my opinion. We are dependent on using the grey matter in order to retain our supremacy. We must be able to distinguish scenarios where actual harm is intended and carried upon and where crude promulgation is used as incitement.
 I found the outcry distressingly disproportionate more so because we do not cry out when our own Pakistani citizens are forced to convert from Hindu to Muslim, when Hindu graves are desecrated or when there are blasts in Churches,when Christian villages are burnt down, when Shia intelligentsia is targeted and doctor after doctor, lawyer after lawyer is killed for solely faith based reasons.Nor when  the policy of appeasement and capitulation to the Taliban continues.When mosques are built after killers like Mumtaz Qadri whilst those orphaned by him watch on, helpless.Nor when the Chief of Ignorance and Repugnance is hailed by naming a library after him.At that time this very same nucleus of “ummah” isn’t outraged. There is no outrage no hysteria in the masses; or in comparison very little.
We have built up resilient immunity to calculated murders and intentional infliction of distress. We have deafened our sensibilities preferring hyper nationalization and sensationalist religion instead.Our partial outrage in it’s exclusivity is beginning to echo of the hollowness with which it is created.
  The major sin of our baseless din is that we suppress the cries of those truly oppressed.We no longer need smoke and mirrors, because with such mirth we have embraced becoming the distraction.

About the author

Alizeh Khaleeli

Photojournalist, wedding photographer & writer inspired by life and it's realities.

21 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • I wonder what made you write this article ?
    Let’s not call it blasphemy , but don’t justify the disrespect shown towards GREAT personalities . As a common educated citizen I am seriously offended by even mentioning names like Ali and Fatima in a show dedicated to Veena Malik ! Let alone dedicating a Qawali (and all this not done in good spirit , just for ratings )

  • میرے خیال میں اس شو میں منقبت کو پیش کئے جانے کے انداز کا نامناسب ہونا ہے یہ کسی بهی شک و شبے سے بالاتر ہے اور منقبت پڑهنے یا سننے کے جو آداب ہوا کرتے ہیں اس سے یہ انحراف کی مثال ہے
    لیکن لقمان مبشر نے اس نامناسب کو توهین یا گستاخی کے زمرے میں لیکر آنا اور اس کے لئے بلاسفمی کا لفظ استعمال کرنا اور اسے باقاعدہ مہمم کا حصہ بنانا وہ عمل ہے جو پاکستان میں دیوبندی تکفیری دہشت گردوں اور ان کے سیاسی چہروں کے ایجنڈے کو براہ راست فائدہ پہنچاتا ہے

    مبشر لقمان کے اس ایجنڈے کو اہل سنت والجماعت نے اپنے ایجنڈے کے لئے اس قدر فائدہ مند پایا کہ انہوں نے اس حوالے سے ملک گیر احتجاج کا سلسلہ شروع کیا اور اپنے بعد نماز جمعہ احتجاجوں میں انہوں نے کہا کہ اگر پاکستانی ریاست طارق اعظم کے توهین اہل بیت و صحابہ مخالف بل کو ایکٹ بنادیتی تو آج یہ دن نہ دیکهنا پڑتا
    اہل سنت والجماعت پاکستان میں ایک اور بلاسفیمی ایکٹ لانا چاہتی ہے جس کابنیادی مقصد شیعہ اور بریلویوں کو اس ایکٹ کے تحت زیادہ سے زیادہ victimise کرنا ہے اور ایسا کوئی ایکٹ بنا تو پهر اس کے تحت گرفتات آدمی کو صقف شفاف ٹرائل کے حق سے محروم کرنا آسان ہوگا اور اس کو کسی وکیل کرنے کے حق سے محروم کرنا بهی جیسے آجکل 295اے بی سی ایکٹ کے تحت گرفتار سخص کو آسان ہے
    اس لئے اہل سنت بریلوی اور اہل تشیع کو اس تازہ مہم کے پیچهے چهپے ایجنڈے کو سمجهنا چاہئیے

  • Every application or maybe application has it has the positives as well as crons consequently the absolutely drastically wrong sighting only the undesirable favorable the item. It includes a lot of the excellent points so that time moves all these disadvantages is going to be soughted available. . -= GadgetGuide4U’s previous weblog… Google Software Regarding Android is actually Avaiable =-.
    louis vuitton outlet http://www.seam-stpaul.org

  • Additionally, in relation to undertaking off-line backups, it is certainly recommended. But that will not guide Cushion Honan if the option and scarier climate happenned: The proven fact that often the cyberpunks worn out the equipment is simply not often the worst type of that could transpire. At the least Pad recognized your dog is hacked a short while following becoming destroyed. What in the event the cyber-terrorist have been far more devious? They’d get invisible the fact that your dog is hacked and also little by little pile up his or her identification data over a long period of your time. With one of these secretly compromised id details, the particular cyber-terrorist may have slowly but surely damaged the existence (eg take out a loan within the brand, squander offences together with identification, employ his current account being a charentaise for cash laundering). It will be considerably more difficult to pass though this type of ‘slow‘ identify. In this particular alternate scenario, backups more than likely conserve the dog. Quality guy have a more diabolical trouble!
    canada goose outlet http://www.goosejacketsoutletsale.com

  • I agree, Microsoft windows main Local area appears to be nice. Absolutely no curiosity about typically the Microsoft windows personal computer devastation, along with are even now awaiting Android mobile phone to get unique intended for tablets although a possibility awful in mobile phones. WebOS has been appealing nevertheless it passed on an easy death. iOS remains ruler of supplements and Macintosh personal computer OPERATING-SYSTEM Back button full involving desktop computer production.
    louis vuitton outlet http://www.picharitydolphin.com

  • Can any person please tell me the way to may help activity selection from elgg page and also revise often the mine as well as buddies page because i want. I want to alter the formatting from the screen if commented around the photograph Good site this is certainly, There are bookmarked as their favorite that in my opera, take care.
    louis vuitton outlet http://www.louisvuittonoutletonlinesd.com

  • ロレックス デイトナ偽物時計:http://www.canot-kayak.qc.ca/rolexwatch.html
    フランクミュラーコピー時計:http://www.iconsinmed.org/cir/franckmullerwatch.html
    オメガコピー時計:http://oiltechinvest.com/omegawatch.html

  • I am just using a problem with the take away ad/unlimited cd improvement. Patient using the no cost software package without having complications, in addition to done the particular cost-free revise through itunes currently without troubles. When i decided to increase the. 99 update, and once We get access along with this i-tunes identification in addition to username and password, it is about backside by having an blunder “This is not the test end user consideration. Remember to create a fresh accounts inside the Sandbox environment. (Environment: Sandbox)”. You won’t keep on. What is the challenge? Cheers!
    louis vuitton outlet http://arcoksa.com

  • John Me dealing with small businesses through Northern SERA and even occurs graphical inside my chats with these. It can be a more efficient one page through watch in the intricate Net local community that everyone needs to be alert to in addition to be involved in. How do i attain your agreement with regard to it’s use? Thank a person Doug
    cheap ugg boots http://www.leftuggboots.com