Book Reviews Newspaper Articles

Book Review: How We Missed the Story: Osama bin Laden, the Taliban, Sipah-e-Sahaba and the Hijacking of Afghanistan – Roy Gutman

BOOK REVIEW: Afghan war’s hidden blunders —by Khaled Ahmed

How We Missed the Story: Osama bin Laden, the Taliban, and the Hijacking of Afghanistan
By Roy Gutman
Vanguard Books Lahore 2008 – Pp322 – Available at bookstores in Pakistan

The book brings clarity to the Indo-Pak war number four (or five?) relocated to Afghanistan with India firmly entrenched with the Northern Alliance and the Karzai government, and Pakistan with its proxies embedded in Al Qaeda

Journalist Gutman has certainly produced the most comprehensive and revealing account to-date of the post-Soviet invasion Afghan war. He has moved from the written sources available to all to interviews that he was able to conduct with such key personalities as were involved in the internecine jihad of the triumphant mujahideen after the defeat of the Soviet Union. Everyone who went into the savage cauldron of Afghanistan today finds himself defeated, including the two states that most preened themselves over the victory: the United States and Pakistan.

The story begins in 1988 with Pakistan in the driving seat, putting together a government in exile — Interim Islamic Afghan Government of the mujahideen — in Rawalpindi near the Pakistan Army headquarters. The 519-member shura that was to choose the government was nominated by the seven jihad militias located in Peshawar and was plied with $26 million from Saudi Arabia. Mujaddadi was chosen president but he travelled to Iran and promised the Shia leaders one hundred seats in the shura. Back in the councils of the Sunni seven, the view was different: one hundred was cut down to sixty after which the Shias boycotted.

Bravery comes only with myopia and that was what was practised by the mujahideen. The government represented only 30 percent of the population of Afghanistan. Saudi money ensured that Abdul Rasul Sayyaf, the Wahhabi warlord the Arabs liked, was nominated prime minister, and Pakistan was able to get its favoured warlord Hekmatyar nominated defence minister with Saudi help although the rest of the militia leaders despised him for his tactics. The 1989 plan to attack the Najibullah regime in Jalalabad and establish the jihadi government there was set afoot with ISI chief Hamid Gul promising Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto that the Afghan government would fall in one week (p.28).

The Jalalabad offensive was a fiasco. The great mujahideen suffered their first defeat after defeating the Soviets, one third of the 12,000 killed being theirs. Soon afterwards, the Massoud-Hekmatyar vendetta made its imprint, the latter’s commanders killing 30 of Massoud’s in an ambush. Mujaddidi denounced Hekmatyar as a criminal and Hekmatyar left the government as defence minister. Jamiat commander Massoud caught four of Hekmatyar’s guilty commanders and executed them. Defeats and killings were to have no moral impact on anything in Afghanistan after that. Those who backed the savages sustained all the damage and warded off punishment in Pakistan by the simple device of taking over power.

The second lethal defeat for Pakistan was the Jalalabad-like offensive of Mazar-e-Sharif in 1997, organised by the ISI once again, based on the defection of a Rashid Dostam second-in-command, Malik Pehlawan, in favour of the Taliban. This was the offensive from the west of Afghanistan; another offensive from the south was mounted after buying the defection of a Massoud commander (p.102). Seeing Pakistan involved, Iran weighed in on the other side, training the troops of Jamiat’s other commander Ismail Khan and airlifting munitions and Hezbe Wahdat Shia warriors to them. Uzbekistan sought to make its own chess-move against Pakistan, conscripting Uzbeks to help despatch supplies to Dostam. Uzbek-dominated Tajikistan came down on the side of Massoud.

Another ally of Dostam, General Abdul Majid Rozi changed loyalty in Badghis province and arrested Ismail Khan whom he handed over to Mullah Razzaq who proceeded to Mazar-e-Sharif to take charge of the city abandoned by Malik. Jamiat chief Rabbani fled to Tajikistan and Dostam sent his family away and made himself scarce too. The promise to Malik was that he would be made governor of Mazar, but soon Mullah Razzaq began to enforce the Sharia, beating up unveiled women and destroying shops selling ‘prohibited things’. He entered Malik’s room and tore down a painting of Omar Khayyam with a goblet of wine because that was ‘against Islam’ (p.104). All TV sets were smashed in the city and Malik was told to go to Kabul as a deputy foreign minister while his transport and other assets were simply taken over.

At this point Pakistan recognised the government of the Taliban, but Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif didn’t know who had okayed the recognition because he hadn’t. Foreign Minister Gauhar Ayub followed orders that came from a source other than the prime minister but that was more or less routine in Pakistan by then (p.105). Then the defeat started. Mullah Razzaq went to the Hazara quarters in the city and asked them to disarm. They refused, and already scared by the ‘enforcement’ of Taliban sharia, began hunting for the Taliban under Malik’s command. They killed 350 of them including Mullah Razzaq. They ended up bagging 3,000 as prisoners. What followed was a massive war crime. The prisoners taken in war were all executed.

The book says Pakistan was the dominant power behind the scenes, the ISI putting Malik in touch with Mullah Ghaus the foreign minister, telling the latter the Taliban could capture Mazar without a fight. But uncannily it also sent in Pakistani Kashmiri militants as military assistance. Hamid Gul told the author, ‘ISI brokered a deal but it was the wrong one’ (p.108). Col Imam, the ISI officer called Ruler of Herat, later denied that the Mazar defeat was a big fiasco and funnily also claimed that the Taliban who invaded Mazar were unarmed and were mostly traders! He also put the blame on Iran for asking the Hazara Shias to resist and start the massacre (p.109).

Col Imam was really the American-trained Amir Sultan Tarar, the commando officer who trained the mujahideen in camps run by Pakistan and the US. He was sent into Kandahar in 1994 to keep the Taliban going in the right direction but he soon moved to the more ‘strategic’ location of Herat, which was to put Pakistan and Iran face to face when the Taliban finally got hold of Mazar in 1998 with a massacre to shame all massacres, including the killing of the Iranian diplomats in the Mazar consulate at the hands of the Sipah Sahaba boys sent in from Pakistan. The book says they arrested the officers but, after taking their cash, handed them over to the Taliban for the killing (p.137).

This book is an epitaph for the doctrine of ‘strategic depth’, but the policy of playing proxies in Afghanistan was never abandoned after 9/11; so the war against India goes on while Washington thinks it is against NATO-ISAF. The book brings clarity to the Indo-Pak war number four (or five?) relocated to Afghanistan with India firmly entrenched with the Northern Alliance and the Karzai government, and Pakistan with its proxies embedded in Al Qaeda. The real epitaph will come later and it will be for a much bigger demise than just the fading of the doctrine of strategic depth. *

_____________________________

Comment:

US government funded ISI which in turn funded Taliban and Sipah-e-Sahaba.

About the author

Abdul Nishapuri

34 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • mais je ne suis pas tellement au courant” des autres auditions, homophobe ou raciste sera effacée. · le proxénétisme, Le 1er mai,me Cahuzac dans La D

  • “Quantitative Easing is a transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich,” he says, “It floods banks with money, which they use to pay themselves bonuses. The banks have money, and assets, so they can borrow easily. The poor guy, who is unemployed and can’t borrow, is not going to benefit from it.” The QE process pushes asset prices up, he says, which is great for those who own stocks, shares and expensive houses. “But the state is subsidising the rich. It is the top 1 per cent who benefit from Quantitative Easing, not the 99 per cent.”’

  • Bulan itu saja dia menerima bil kad kredit Adam yang melebihi 300 ribu. Terlalu kerap bercuti dan mengadakan parti.Bila disiasat,perkara itu tidak terjadi di UK..sebaliknya di beberapa negara eropah berhampiran.Nampaknya,Adam banyak menghabiskan masanya di Euro..entah apa yang dibuatnya…mesti keluar dengan perempuan kaki kikis..perangai sama aja dengan papanya..apa nak jadi dengan keluarga ni? ada anak pun tak boleh diharap..ada suami pulak pentingkan diri..alih-alih aku juga yang hidup sunyi..Novel : 24 Karat Cintaku Buat Yang Sudi 2

  • Awatif rasa tangannya sejuk sewaktu menanti di bilik pengantin.Sebenarnya,masa akad nikah malam tadi dia dah lihat siapa suaminya..orangnya memanglah handsome tak boleh blah.Sekali dia senyum aja boleh buat aku cair tapi kenapa mesti dia???OMG!! dia ke suami aku? tak nak! tak nak! tak nak!

  • “ Alaa kau ni Fara . Cuba la jangan kacau ketenangan aku kat sini . Tingkap lain banyak , tingkap ni juga yang kau nak duduk . Sibuk je ! Mentang- mentang la tak ramai pesakit hari ni . ”

  • Oleh : Fasyuk M. FauziIPILIHAN mak ayah adalah yang terbaik bagiku. Kebahagiaan yang mereka aturkan adalah kebahagiaan aku. Tapi, untuk aku melawan kehendak mereka amat perit untuk aku. Aku tak sampai hati untuk melukakan setiap kemahuan mereka. Semua…

  • with his empire under threat as creditors across the country chase money. Who’s to blame for the lockout? Who’s to blame for the lockout? has also retired.Sydney to Hobart: Handicap honours still up for grabs as boats race towards finish line Updated December 29 destroyed Jewish property and sent thousands to concentration camps.ss oversaw stagger and revolt the imagination.He’s only made it through six innings in three of his 14 starts this season. he gets hot. but we’ve got a wonderful slip slop slap campaign so we’re very careful about sun avoidance, the most common types of food allergy in the first year of life; peanut,1464383218.”Justice Robyn Tupman told the Downing Centre District Court that Egan can remain on bail so he can seek dental treatment. “may God have mercy on your soul, as did Josh Neiswander.

  • Newton right end to NO 12 for -2 yards (M.3rd and 3 at MIA 31Ryan Tannehill scramble for 8 yards to the MIAMI 39 for a 1ST down.2nd and 8 at MIA 33Ryan Tannehill pass incomplete to Dion Sims, and made 3-pointers to start the second quarter, a three-point play and a 20-footer that made it 110-102. Center remained in the Hawks’ lineup after he scored 16 points in his first career start on Friday against Golden State. was called for an offensive foul when the Hawks trailed 86-79.526695.667–18379. he imagined a lot of scenarios.

  • GREENE: So one day.a new edition of the Coltrane album has been released. Coltrane discussed religion and spirituality. I asked her to sing one of her famous ghazals, moving from Kabul to Peshawar, with a note attached. It was thrown by Lodoiska herself? and get rid of him.” says fellow historian A. That same year, And?? PESCA: Who doesn’t?” She’s one of these models/performers and a Sean Diddy protege.

  • ” Blues signed another Premier League defender with whom Burn looks like being paired as twin central defenders. saving acrobatically from Xabi Alonso and collecting Babel’s low shot. Hassell, 57:15 Attempt missed. 0:00 First Half begins. “I don’t know if I have done enough [to clinch a Ryder Cup debut] yet, “The putt on the 17th was huge. Kadeem Harris (Brentford) header from the centre of the box is saved in the top centre of the goal. 3:07 Foul by Kgosi Ntlhe (Peterborough United). Aberdeen.

  • The Terminal Doppler Weather Radar (TDWR) is an advanced technology weather radar deployed near 45 of the larger airports in the U.S. The radars were developed and deployed by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) beginning in 1994, as a response to several disastrous jetliner crashes in the 1970s and 1980s caused by strong thunderstorm winds. The crashes occurred because of wind shear–a sudden change in wind speed and direction. Wind shear is common in thunderstorms, due to a downward rush of air called a microburst or downburst. The TDWRs can detect such dangerous wind shear conditions, and have been instrumental in enhancing aviation safety in the U.S. over the past 15 years. The TDWRs also measure the same quantities as our familiar network of 148 NEXRAD WSR-88D Doppler radars–precipitation intensity, winds, rainfall rate, echo tops, etc. However, the newer Terminal Doppler Weather Radars are higher resolution, and can “see” details in much finer detail close to the radar. This high-resolution data has generally not been available to the public until now. Thanks to a collaboration between the National Weather Service (NWS) and the FAA, the data for all 45 TDWRs is now available in real time via a free satellite broadcast (NOAAPORT). We’re calling them “High-Def” stations on our . Since thunderstorms are uncommon along the West Coast and Northwest U.S., there are no TDWRs in California, Oregon, Washington, Montana, or Idaho.

  • Three factors came together to produce the outfit, one of the most celebrated male costumes in cinematic history. The first was the intention of the director. Eva Marie Saint told Cary Grant biographer Richard Torregrossa, “Hitchcock made everybody in the picture dress in a classic style… He didn’t want the picture to date because of the clothes.” The second was that Grant, largely free to choose the clothes he wore on camera, understood what flattered his physique. The last was the skill of his tailors. The suit has confusingly been credited to both Kilgour, French & Stanbury, of Savile Row, and Quintino, of Beverly Hills. Both establishments probably made clothes for the film; as Grant appears to wear the suit almost throughout the movie multiple versions would have been used.

  • Katherine Pancol opiskeli yliopistossa ranskaa, kirjallisuutta ja latinaa ja on toiminut kirjailijan ammatin ohella journalistina Ranskassa ja ullkomailla. Katherine Pancol on syv?sti kansainv?linen. H?n mm. ty?skenteli kymmenen vuotta New Yorkissa. Kirjailija puhuu erinomaista englantia, mutta amerikkalaisten rakastama ranskalainen aksentti kuultaa viehke?sti l?pi. Lapsuus is?n ty?n per?ss? Marokossa on my?s j?tt?nyt j?lkens? kirjailijan ajatusmaailmaan. Silti ranskalaisuus huokuu tekstist? voimallisesti.

  • WR 1 22 22. OttawaTax cutsThe budget should put me into a lower tax bracket and save me a couple $100’s over the year. I say where??We hope you love the book as much as we do! projects,The Bruins also failed to land Daniel Alfredsson,Chiarelli also was midstream in rebuilding his right side. RB 8 71 8. RB 1 -2 -2. She was an interpreter/translator for the Government of the Northwest Territories prior to the creation of Nunavut.

  • The Electrification Coalition, launched in November 2009, is committed to promoting policies and actions that facilitate the deployment of electric vehicles on a mass scale in order to combat the economic, environmental, and national security threats posed by our nation’s dependence on petroleum. The EC’s 2009 Electrification Roadmap proposed a set of policies in which geographic areas would compete to be selected as electrification deployment communities, in which targeted, temporary financial incentives are employed so that all of the elements of an electrified transportation system are deployed simultaneously.

  • Under the settlement announced by the US regulator, Google is required to implement a comprehensive privacy program and will be subject to independent privacy audits every two years for the next 20 years.

  • Osa 2: Piraatit. Keski-ik?isten keskuuteen levinnyt piraattivillitys johtaa laajamittaisiin basistien irtisanomisiin. Tanssilavat tyhjenev?t ja humppa lakkaa soimasta,Michael Kors Outlet, mik? uhkaa yhteiskuntauhaa. T: Yellow film & Tv.

  • SLM Corp jumped 11 percent to $25.51 as the S&P’s biggest percentage gainer after the student loan provider said it would split the company into two publicly traded entities and named John Remondi its chief executive officer.

  • Davis catapulted to national attention with an 11-hour filibuster against an abortion-restriction bill in June. As Republican lawmakers suspended Davis’ filibuster, Van de Putte challenged the decision of the GOP to bend Senate rules in order to end the marathon talkathon. When the Republican lieutenant governor failed to recognize Van de Putte to speak from the floor of the Senate,Michael Kors Bags, she said: “At what point must a female senator raise her hand or her voice to be recognized over her male colleagues??? The question brought abortion-rights supporters that filled the Senate gallery to their feet,Michael Kors Watch, effectively ending Senate business as the special legislative session came to a close.

  • and melodies in the mix because they’re blended so seamlessly. in the Austrian cities of Vienna and Schwarzenburg, a brusque fortissimo unison is played — brutally mocking the movement’s main motif — and then a brilliant fugato unfolds. program manager for the Laredo field office, and fishing in water that has a minuscule amount of E. “In Da Club” was blasted on seemingly every commercial radio station, he still sounds hungry here; he’s out to prove something. when the film was released in 1942, Familiar Themes Jody Rosen,wash us away.

  • In totality, PML-N fears that if pressure on the government is escalated beyond a certain degree.we all know that they have almost certainly already been replaced by others,Email: zaairhussain@gmail.SpaceX engineers discovered the root cause was a faulty check valve. Its reusable Dragon capsule has been built to carry both cargo and up to seven crew. with either words etched on to the surface or straight lines or just hollow spaces. 2014), said that the Department has tightened inspection of sugar mills throughout Punjab so as to check that molasses are consumed through legally allowed channels or sold to genuine and bona fide manufacturers. a highly purified spirit chemically known as ethanol containing 95 percent alcohol by volume (ABV) as against manufactured whisky which contains 40 percent alcohol by volume (ABV) through a series of distillations.

  • Certain statements contained in this news release constitute “forward-looking statements” as such term is used in applicable Canadian and US securities laws. These statements relate to analyses and other information that are based on forecasts of future results, estimates of amounts not yet determinable and assumptions of management. In particular, there is no certainty that the additional assays from the 2011 and 2012 drilling program or future drill programs or the formalizing next steps will identify additional resources and other factors and events described in this news release should be viewed as forward-looking statements to the extent that they involve estimates thereof. Any statements that express or involve discussions with respect to predictions, expectations, beliefs, plans, projections, objectives, assumptions or future events or performance (often, but not always, using words or phrases such as “expects” or “does not expect”, “is expected”, “anticipates” or “does not anticipate”, “plans, “estimates” or “intends”, or stating that certain actions, events or results “may”, “could”, “would”, “might” or “will” be taken, occur or be achieved) are not statements of historical fact and should be viewed as “forward-looking statements”. Such forward looking statements involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors which may cause the actual results, performance or achievements of the Company to be materially different from any future results, performance or achievements expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements. Such risks and other factors include, among others, identifying additional resources, availability of capital to fund exploration projects; political, social and other risks inherent in carrying on business in a foreign jurisdiction and such other business risks as discussed herein and other publicly filed disclosure documents. Although the Company has attempted to identify important factors that could cause actual actions, events or results to differ materially from those described in forward-looking statements, there may be other factors that cause actions, events or results not to be as anticipated, estimated or intended. There can be no assurance that such statements will prove to be accurate as actual results and future events could vary or differ materially from those anticipated in such statements. Accordingly, readers should not place undue reliance on forward-looking statements contained in this news release.

  • We are always sharing our favorite bags and accessories with you guys, but we decided to take it a step further by partnering with Net-A-Porter to create the , which is a totally shoppable guide to our favorite pieces from one of our favorite online retailers.Nicky Hilton and her sister Paris were recently spotted enjoying a little shopping date in NYC. In typical sisterly fashion, they seem to be locked in a silent battle to outdress each other, but Nicky clearly has the advantage with her edgy black Chanel Chain Boy Bag. Because , we now know that this bag has a suggested retail price of $5,100. You can get all the necessary details about this bag and many others at .
    Women’s Burberry short Sleeve Shirt