Culture & Arts Featured Original Articles

Where Hamid Mir and Ejaz Haider converge: Politicians, not army, responsible for #ShiaGenocide

shia

Related post: Good Liberals and Good Taliban of Pakistan stand united with Pak Fauj – by Syed Riaz Al-Malik Hajjaji

In his long apologia for Pakistan army’s inaction against Takfiri Deobandi terrorists of ASWJ-LeJ (formerly known as Sipah-e-Sahaba), Ejaz Haider claims that political parties, PML-N in particular but also PPP, ANP and other parties, are responsible for Shia genocide because they are reluctant to use army to take action against ASWJ-LeJ terrorists.

Ejaz Haider writes (Express Tribune, 26 Feb 2013):

What about the army and the ISI; how do they look at this phenomenon? (LeJ’s attacks on Shias)
Short answer: they are greatly worried. Next question: what are they doing about it?
Short answer: not much.
Central question: why the hell not? This requires a longer answer and some perspective.
Fact 1: The total strength of the army is about 550,000 troops. Out of this, around 110,000 are deployed in the operational areas in the west. Approximately 60,000 to 70,000 are deployed along the Line of Control as part of 10 Corps and Force Command Northern Areas. The rest are in peacetime locations, to be mobilised to defend the eastern border when required. Additionally, there are a number of other command and staff duties to be performed.
Fact 2: Armies generally operate on the 33.33 per cent principle. At any time, 33.33 per cent are deployed, the same percentage is in training and equal numbers, more or less, are resting and retrofitting. Pakistan’s internal war has thrown this awry. The deployment has gone up to 44 to 45 per cent, training retains the same percentage and the resting and retrofitting has gone down to about 12 percent. The ops areas tenure has upped from 22 months to over two years and a high percentage of units are now awaiting second and third rotation to the ops areas. Evidently a killer.
Fact 3: The Pakistan Military Academy has had to raise the 4th Pak Battalion because the internal war has taken a heavy toll of young officers. The officer-to-soldier kill ratio is very high, upped from 1:16 to 1:14 and now stands at 1:8. This means a shortage of YOs. (Some officers consider it a matter of pride; I consider it a weakness but that’s a separate topic.)
Corollary: the army is stretched thin. It cannot be everywhere and, quite apart from operations to wrest territory, is not meant to address the problem of urban terrorism. Even the counterterrorism sub-units in the Special Services Group, like the Zarar and Karar companies, are meant for fire-fighting, not gathering intelligence and pre-empting.
And the ISI? It has the capacity to gather intel and it does. But equally, there are other organisations like the police, the Intelligence Bureau and the CID units whose primary job is to gather intel. Why are they not effective? Answer: when political governments make alliances with the very terrorists these organisations are supposed to bust, then they cannot be effective. There are other reasons too but this is the primary one.
And when Frontier Corps does get involved, sending terrorists to their afterlife, as in Quetta, the leaders of these organisations invoke the law and register cases against the FC.

Source: If a Shia, you are on your own, Ejaz Haider, Express Tribune, February 26, 2013 http://tribune.com.pk/story/512887/if-a-shia-you-are-on-your-own/

Similar “blame politicians, exonerate army” discourse is offered by Hamid Mir in his column in daily Jang (28 Feb 2013). Mir generously and uncritically quotes Army Chief General Kayani to assert that political government, not army, is reluctant to take action against ASWJ-LeJ terrorists.

hamid mir
Source: Election kay baad kiya ho ga, Hamid Mir, http://jang.com.pk/jang/feb2013-daily/28-02-2013/col2.htm

Counter-view

In her article in Express Tribune (28 Feb 2013), Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa offers a counter-view, convincingly arguing that it is Pakistan army, not politicians, who are primarily and ultimately responsible for the current state of Deobandi-Wahhabi violence:

The PML-N government was not always like this. It had contested the SSP/LeJ network during the 1990s, but with little support from the establishment. For instance, when Nawaz Sharif and his brother screamed their heads off about sectarian violence in Pakistan and Punjab, they were contradicted by the Foreign Office. The Sharif government of the 1990s also targeted the LeJ resulting in a botched terrorist attack on the then prime minister, Nawaz Sharif. The LeJ terrorist leader Riaz Basra also threatened them. This was a point when a combined intelligence and police operation could have helped but it didn’t happen. Moreover, the government was dismissed in 1999. There is certainly a possibility that the Sharifs got scared.

The Pakistan and Punjab of the 2000s was different in terms of its relationship with terror groups which were being neatly put to order, rearranged and regrouped. The number in Punjab fell from about 70 odd militant groups (small and large) in the 1990s to a few large ones. However, these were protected and had links with the agencies and continue to do so. The government in Punjab and the police were not authorised to question and challenge most of these groups. Police officers often complain of situations when they arrest terrorists who are later whisked away from police stations by other more powerful intelligence agencies. It was certainly not the PML-N that had allowed organisations like the Jaish-e-Mohammad (JeM) to walk in and out of the Pakistan Air Force, whose officers were later involved in one of the assassination attempts on Pervez Musharraf. Interestingly, the JeM continues to be treated as a good friend and allowed to expand infrastructure. The logic for continued friendship is that the operation was conducted by splinter groups and not the mother organisation.

Moreover, at that point in time even the media was not too keen to hear about jihadis in Punjab. I remember in 2007-08 no one in the larger civil society was ready to hear about the problem in Punjab. In fact, when a New York Times journalist did a story about the problem, a local English daily went out of its way to counter the report and do several stories negating the presence of extremist elements in Punjab. In fact, Mushtaq Sukhera, the senior police officer, who has been dispatched to Quetta to fight LeJ, was then RPO Bahawalpur and vehemently denied a jihadi presence in south Punjab. He even claimed that the JeM madrassa on the main GT Road was ordered to stop any further construction. However, those orders, if there were any, were never carried out.

More than personal inefficiency, this was about the real powers continuing to support the JeM and other Deobandi and Ahle Hadith militant groups.

The decade of the 2000s is also the period when a lot of the militant organisations were allowed to go underground, which meant spreading in society far and wide. They started building their social clout, which the intelligence agencies now believe can be capitalised in mainstreaming these organisations and thus taking them away from violence. It is definitely not any political government’s idea to bring the militants into politics as it goes against the logic of electoral politics. More parties mean more concessions and dividing the vote bank. Until now, supporters of all jihadi networks happily voted for one or the other party without burdening them with any consolidated demands. However, it is now that they are being made to think of forming their own political platform. Sadly, the mainstream political parties are happy to go along and do seat adjustment partly because of their inability to openly challenge Zia’s children. Such cowardice is not forgivable but it is essential to understand the context.

These jihadis will disappear the day their creators run out of uses for them. They were raised initially during the 1980s but integrated in the tactical planning, as indicated in one of the papers produced at GHQ, to play the role of additional division to fight India. Later, they were put to multiple uses. These will get costly with time especially if they are not needed after 2014. In any case, these are risky assets to maintain in a nuclear environment. Going by the splinter-group theory, what if they start an accidental war? Getting rid of them at this stage is not hugely difficult either. In Punjab and Sindh, where these are spreading rapidly, they could be removed through an intense intelligence and police operation. It is mainly the intent and planning that could get things going.

Critical Reaction on Twitter:

1

2

3

4

5

End note: Right-wing Fake Liberal Alliance The similarity of discourse between a seemingly liberal English columnist Ejaz Haider and right-wing Urdu columnist Hamid Mir is not coincidental. This confirms our long held theory that both Islamists in Urdu media and fake liberals in English media remain loyal to the narratives and agendas of the Deep State. Also, there is ample evidence that both groups promote each other. A few weeks ago, some pro-establishment fake liberals (including Akram Lahori’s NGO-liberal niece and director of a pro-establishment think tank) were seen praising and promoting Hamid Mir and a certain Deobandi cleric. A few months ago, a funny columnist tried to convince us that Ejaz Haider, Najam Sethi and Hamid Mir are anti-establishment journalists. This Noora Kushti is deceptive as well as entertaining.

About the author

SK

40 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Comments on Dr. Siddiqa’s piece:

    bangash
    Feb 28, 2013 – 12:14AM
    Reply
    These jihadis and their use in militancy has cost the lives of thousands of Pakistanis and $50 billion plus in damage, how on earth can the Establishment still look at these groups as “useful” ?
    Recommend53

    3rdRockFromTheSun
    Feb 28, 2013 – 12:47AM
    Reply
    These jihadis will disappear the day their creators run out of uses for them. … Getting rid of them at this stage is not hugely difficult either.
    That ship seems to have sailed. I think it is now beyond the will and capability of your political and military establishment to get rid of them. What remains to be seen is how fast this fire engulfs what is left of Pakistan.

    MSS
    Feb 28, 2013 – 1:26AM
    Reply
    An informative article.
    If the militant groups still have links with the agencies and can be controlled and disarmed, then it is an admission that the agencies are ignoring their activities of murder and killings. That makes them accomplices to wanton killings. Since the civilian government does not want these killings, it is clear that the security agencies report to no one in Pakistan and that blaming the foreign powers is just a stock response and the public fall for it every time.

    Aly shafa
    Feb 28, 2013 – 1:38AM
    Reply
    it mean army is the real source of shia killing in Pakistan backing the extremist group its so sad , nice report with too many information no one shared yet, would you like to write on this tpoic with more focus on funding sources of killers

    Comments on Ejaz Haider’s article:

    jawad
    Feb 26, 2013 – 11:50PM
    Reply
    Writer is a known journalist and a how he defends the isi or establishment what ever you call it. Execellent work mr ijaz haider you will be rewarded for ur services for this pro isi article. A job well done. If our army want something done they do it as they did with soviets (russia\afgan) and talibans in swat valley. Pak army mercenaries r famous bahrain hired rtd army officers to get rid of shia uprising n they were very effective against shias in bahrain point is saudis ideology is injected in shape of oil and donations to. Pak army and then to madrassas u can kill a talib but not the doctrine of talib.

  • Shaheen Sehbai of Jang Group too peddles and prmotes General Kayani’s discourse against political government:

    Examples of the civilians’ failure that he quoted, in his own soft style and in a non-intrusive way, were many but a cool analysis of his thoughts and ideas reveals he has told the government and politicians they had messed up in a big way and no more of this mess-up can be afforded.

    For instance, he says on the key issue of war against terrorism, the army is not to be blamed but the civilians have not formulated a comprehensive anti-terrorism policy and they could not decide what to do. They threw the ball in the court of the army without giving them policy guidelines, the targets to be achieved and the way that was to be done.

    Repeatedly, he said that the army had not been consulted or taken on board about the political all parties conferences being held on counter terrorism.

    General Kayani, in this context, quoted many examples and reminded the media men of the Swat situation where he said the President was persuaded by him to take a decision. He also took ANP leader Asfandyar Wali to the President and when the decision was taken to talk to Maulana Sufi Mohammed, the talks were held but when he violated the accord, an operation was launched. Then the civilians had to take over the responsibility which, he implied, they did not.

    General Kayani specifically mentioned the arrests made in Swat and complained that if the arrested persons are not convicted because of lack of evidence, the army cannot hold them forever. For three-and-a-half years it is holding these people and is either violating laws by doing so or risks more terrorism if they are released.

    Likewise, in Balochistan, General Kayani said, an army operation could be launched only if the civilians take that decision and order the army to do so. But once the operation is done and people are arrested, they will again have to be tried and convicted by the police and courts for which the civilians are not prepared and ready.

    Similarly, he said the civilians depend too much and remain forever scared of the ISI and army intelligence agencies whereas the tasks should have been done by their own agencies.

    All internal matters have to be handled by the civilians as the ISI has to look after external intelligence threats and the army has to secure borders. Where are the civilian agencies? he asked, in so many words, though politely.

    General Kayani’s talk was almost a report card of failure of the interior ministry but he said in so many words that for five years the army took all these failures in its stride, and sometimes guided the civilians to reform and take ownership and responsibility yet did not intervene to stop the rot.

    – See more at: http://www.thenews.com.pk/Todays-News-13-21262-General-Kayani-spills-the-beans-blames-others-raises-doubts#sthash.dLvYRUCU.dpuf

  • MQM’s shaking hands with Aurangzeb Faruqi who’d promised to cut off Shias from rest of the population is extension of what GHQ is up to. MQM was the only party that condemned MWM after its historic protests. Now MWM’s members are being arrested and killed in Karachi. All this points to the fact that Shias have no future in the country. MQM here in Karachi will lose all its Shia vote bank. PPP is on the same path. Marginalization of the Shias is a negative development for the future of Pakistan.

  • Design: Whenever you purchase a custom purse, remain certain it won’t ever walk out design. Custom labeling associated with clothing usually strategy their own forthcoming colours as well as designs prior to this strikes the marketplace. For this reason this gets hard to complement in the most recent style from time to time. Whilst there’s nothing like this using the custom purses. These people usually cause you to presentable and not walk out design.

  • The clog design of shoe is coming again in a huge way and MBT is ahead of the pack as usual. The Kipimo type is wonderful for operating out in the property, operating a few of errands, or just slipping on when you are in a hurry. You can acquire the Kipimo in possibly black leather or chocolate leather and suede. Every single of these attributes adorable flower stencil cutouts around the top rated of the shoe. They attach to your foot through a strap in the again. You will look and come to feel at ease and informal in the Kipimo.

  • This website definitely has all of the information I wanted concerning this subject and didn’t
    know who to ask.

    Here is my blog post; garcinia cambogia and green coffee bean free trial
    (Lorri)

  • Very rapidly this website will be famous among all blog users, due to it’s nice articles
    or reviews

    Here is my blog; garcinia cambogia free trial women’s health
    (Lilla)

  • Hi there, I discovered your web site by means of Google even as looking for a similar subject, your web site got here up, it appears
    to be like good. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

    Hello there, just become alert to your blog via Google, and located that it is really informative.
    I am going to be careful for brussels. I’ll be grateful for those who proceed this in future.
    A lot of other people will be benefited out of your writing.
    Cheers!

    Here is my web page :: best auto repair shop shop portales

  • Undeniably believe that which you stated. Your favorite reason appeared to
    be on the web the easiest thing to be aware of. I say
    to you, I definitely get irked while people think about worries
    that they plainly do not know about. You managed to hit the
    nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without
    having side-effects , people could take a signal. Will probably be back to get more.
    Thanks

    Stop by my page; lasik prices

  • After I initially commented I seem to have clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and from now on each time a comment is
    added I get four emails with the same comment.

    Is there a means you are able to remove me from that service?
    Thanks a lot!

    Feel free to surf to my blog post: rehab mortgage loans queens

  • Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed!

    Very helpful info specifically the last part 🙂 I care for such information much.
    I was seeking this particular info for a long time. Thank you and good luck.

  • and not so optimistic,3 percent on layups last season). attempted 281 Kevin Costners “back, who has been playing in Russia during the lockout,Howard was a key player for Dallas from 2003-10 and helped the Mavs in their run to the NBA Finals in 2006. percentage of drives ending in a touchdown or field goal, Alabama is allowing just a 22. but those two and a focused preseason sealed it. Wholly unexpected FT issues for D-Wade. MCW for ROY?