Original Articles

Killings of Shia Bohras leave apologists with no justifications – by Hasan Lotia

Related post: Shia Bohras of Karachi are Takfiri terrorists’ new target

Shias of Pakistan are suffering genocide in the country they played a vital role in creating. Thousands of Shias have been killed by the state-sponsored jihadi outfits in the last 3 decades but their plight has been considered unimportant to be cared for by the State,  civil society and the intelligentsia. The right-wing nuts as well as the so-called liberals, both of whom have had their different shares in the public sphere have unfortunately either ignored the killings of Shias, obfuscated the issue, or even worse, justified it. But the recent bombing of Hyderi market, a center of the Bohra Shia community in Karachi, has left all these people bereft of any further justifications.

Previously, the, ironically similar, justifications/misrepresentations proffered by both right-wing nuts and fake liberals have been:

  1. What is happening in Pakistan is sectarian violence of reciprocal nature in which both the antagonists: Shias and Sunnis, are killing each other.
  2. The sectarian situation in Pakistan is actually a Saudi-Iran proxy war.  By reinforcing this, apologists wittingly or unwittingly, also paint all Shias of Pakistan as Iranian agents and fifth columnists).
  3. Shias are killed for disrespecting/abusing a few companions of the Holy Prophet (pbuh) (to prove the claim, they might as well present a few references from some books or share online videos)
  4. Shias (for example in case of Shia-Hazara in Quetta, and those from Gilgit-Baltistan and Parachinar) are being killed due to external, geostrategic factors, and at times even directly by the so-called external enemies.
  5. Shias were part of the Islamization process initiated by Bhutto and were responsible for declaring Ahmedis as apostates, they, therefore, deserve the fate they are subjected to.

To the right-wing nuts I have nothing to say.  I would have surely despised them if I had given them a second thought, but I do want to address those who stand (or think that they stand) on the other parts of the political spectrum.

None of the above-mentioned justifications hold water anyway and have been disproved on several occasions at different fora. But except a few honorable exceptions even celebrated liberals and human rights champions of Pakistan, and the kings and queens (and jokers) of the Kingdom of Social Media and journalism are not ready to embrace the obvious, which is:

Shias, irrespective of cast, ethnicity, area and profession are being killed in large numbers, which should now be termed, categorically and unequivocally, as genocide.

Even if Shia Genocide was  evident, it was previously ignored, obfuscated or justified by fake liberals. But this heinous act against the peace-loving, business-oriented Shia Bohra community leaves them with no more justifications, because:

  1. Bohras are an apolitical group, and were neither previously targeted, nor do they have any history of militancy.
  2. The Bohras have nothing to do with Iran, have not received any support, funding or weapons from it.
  3. Bohras do not engage in tabbarra.
  4. The Bohras have a small population and have nothing to do with the unnecessarily bloated geopolitical issues.
  5. Bohras were not responsible for declaring Ahmedis as apostates and certainly did not join hands with Bhutto for Islamization of Pakistan.

While even the Twelver Shias cannot be blamed for most of what Bohras have been absolved of, but the latter were previously somewhat lucky, and at times even presented to other Shias as example. We have heard that Bohras are not attacked because they are apolitical, do not do tabbarra, and aren’t an Iranian proxy.

But now the Bohras too have been attacked. And this leaves our liberal friends with few options left at their disposal to continue misrepresenting Shia Genocide.

They should either prove that Lashkar-e-Jhangvi was not involved in targeting Shia-Bohras (as some did), or admit, as much as they don’t want to, and say, as much as they can’t, that Shias (along with moderate Sunnis, Sufis, Ahmedis, Christians and Hindus) are being killed by Takfiri Deobandis who do not need to have reasons beyond their identity to kill Shias. Shias are being killed by the state-sponsored jihadis because they are Shias. Period.

About the author



Click here to post a comment
  • How would you describe someone distributing the antisemitic hoax ‘The Protocols of the Elders of Zion’ (purporting to describe a Jewish plan for global domination) in Nazi Germany when Hitler and his security forces were slaughtering six million European Jews (The Holocaust). Of course, that would tantamount to enabling further violence against innocent Jews.

    Well, that is exactly what Tarek Fatah did only two days ago when he distributed a highly inflammatory video in which a few Shia youths were shown insulting the Prophet Muhammad’s wife Ayesha.


  • Not unlike millions of peaceful Sunnis in Pakistan and other countries, I too condemn massacre of innocent Shia Muslims at the hands of Saudi-sponsored Takfiri Salafi-Deobandi militants in Pakistan. It is a known fact that majority of peaceful Sunnis reject violence and terrorism by Takfiri terrorists of Lashkar-e-Jhangvi, Sipah-E-Sahaba, Taliban etc.

    However, according to Tarek Fatah, all Sunnis must be blame for the massacre of Shias right from the murder of Hazrat Ali (R.A.) to the current Shia genocide in Pakistan. This is not only worst form of stereotyping but also cruelly insensitive.

    A few days ago, Tarek had blamed Shia Muslims for their own massacre and distributed a highly sectarian video on his facebook and Twitter pages. However, this time, Tarek went further in his insensitivity and blamed all Sunnis for the murder of Shia brothers in Pakistan and other countries. It is a known fact that Takfiri Salafi-Deobandis represent a tiny radicalized segment of Sunni Muslims and must not be stereotyped or described as Sunnis.

    Tarek Fatah ‏@TarekFatah
    Pakistan’s Urdu-speaking and Punjabi sunnis r puppets of Saudis while the Shias r parrots of the Iran as both deny their Indianess @sushobhan

    Tarek Fatah ‏@TarekFatah
    Slaughter of Shia began with Ali assassination in 661AD, and has continued for the last 1,400 years. Their killers hv been Sunnis. @munaeem

    Tarek Fatah ‏@TarekFatah
    Whats wrong with Pakistani Shias? While it is Sunni jihadis who massacre them, they protest not their Pakistani killers, but Israel and USA.

    Of course, a reductionist account of holding Sunnis responsible for Shia genocide also exonerate the Jihadist State which is sponsoring Takfiris in Pakistan and also the US support to Saudi Arbia, the hub of global Takfiri Salafi ideology.

    Does Tarek want Shias of Pakistan to react against Sunnis and wants to ignite a civil war?


  • As a Sunni Hanafi Muslim, I condemn Tarek Fatah’s insult against Hazrat Abu Talib (May Allah be pleased with him), the benefactor and beloved uncle of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him).

    On Twitter, two days ago, Tarek declared Hazrat Abu Talib (R.A.) as an infidel (Kafir).

    Tarek Fatah ‏@TarekFatah
    @ahadhussain @abdulnishapuri Abu Talib was not a Muslim. What is the issue? He never converted to Islam. That is a fact.

    I ask: is Tarek an Islamic Mufti to declare fatwa of anyone’s infidelity (kufr) or Islam? Who has given him the authority to declare anyone Kafir? How is he different from other Takfiri mullahs who declare Sufi Sunnis, Ahmadis, Shiites etc as Kafir? Why did he choose to present an opinion of kufr (naooz billah) of Hazrat Abu Talib which reflects a Salafist mindset and account?


  • Yet, another murder of innocent Shias, yet another crime by Ludhianvi-Malik Ishaq and their protectors in Army.

  • Well no body receives funds from Iran. On the other hand they(the extremists) have always been receiving funds from Saudi Arabia. I’ve seen a lot of those Madrasas (DAR UL ULOOM ARABIA SAUDIA). It’s only nowadays that they are changing their names.

    Pakistani society is a beggar society and a society of assassins they take money and do any thing they are asked to. A terribly divided society horizontally and vertically among ethnicities and religious-sects. Pakistan is doomed, no one can save it now. No even God. It’s gone!!!

  • itssss amazing varieties……… best…….!!!! many thanks quite a lot to get expressing as well as saving everybody’s time frame…….. thank you I want to be aware of 80g this season. If we can certainly analyze 80G inside memory foam not any 16 or not I might considering a new Metro-only product by Xbox the use, I prefer often the hardwood user interface, although There are absolutely no desire for House windows like a desktop OPERATING-SYSTEM nowadays. Lots of malware, spyware, dives, so many problems. The particular Macintosh personal computer is often a superior pc OS devoid of any collisions as well as issues, though the ipad tablet in my opinion looks like some sort of toy even now and it’s unattainable significant work upon it besides writing and reading a number of short e-mail. My partner and i think that is a restriction in order to tablets, yet Microsof company is surely an workplace output firm next time anyone can certainly accomplish some sort of successful gadget its these individuals.

  • I have been seeking with a essential document as well. We e-mailed the item in addition to copied it over to discover the idea would not perform. I aren’t eliminate the essential I actually extra. Do you have had almost any good fortune having ssh keys?