Original Articles

Dr Amna Buttar and Sherry Rehman object to Jamat-ul-Dawah funding by the Punjab government

Dr Amna Buttar and Sherry Rehman are amongst a few brave parliamentarians who have always  raised issues which are not normally raised in our parliament. Dr Buttar is the only parliamentarian  who has consistently raised the issues of (lack of) progress on Gojra massacre in Punjab assembly . On Friday , she raised concern over an alleged allocation of Rs 8 million for Jamatud Dawa; sadly at that time no PML-N minister was present in the assembly.

Sherry Rehman also raised the issue of Jamatud Dawa funding of 82 million on Friday, she wondered why no one has questioned the grant made by the Punjab government .

From Tribune:

Referring to a recent report in the media in which the Punjab Law Minister, Rana Sanaullah, has actually confessed to making such a provision in the budget for its welfare activities, Sherry Rehman demanded that such grants to banned outfits be stopped forthwith, as welfare activities can be taken over by the Punjab government itself, or handed over to a number of non-extremist organizations who can supplement state capacity in this respect.

“Giving an outright grant to the JuD, when it has been banned, tells us that some elements in the Punjab government are still not committed fully to the idea that jihadist outfits like the LeT, with known leadership and cadre links to the JuD, must be rooted out and that their activities shut down,” said Rehman.

“The country can no longer afford this mollycoddling of terrorists, and Punjab is fast becoming a victim of its own ambiguity. There can be no military operation against terrorists in Punjab, but there must and should be a police sweep, with enough evidence to obtain convictions through our courts,” she added.

“Instead of building police capacity to throw such a dragnet around terrorists, who openly hold rallies in the streets of Lahore and Rawalpindi, we see money being doled out of the tax-payers pockets through the annual budgetary exercise. If this is not pampering a banned outfit, what is?” asked Rehman.

“We are told that the government appointed an administrator to run these schools and dispensaries two years ago, but by now this infrastructure should have been taken over by the state, instead of allowing a banned organisation to earn support on JuD and LeT branding. And if its only an administrator that is using the funds, why has Rs79 million of this grant gone directly to the Markaz-i- Tayyaba in Muridke which is the JuD headquarters?” the MNA inquired.

Adding that the federal government should also take note of space being granted to banned outfits through such disbursements and rallies, Rehman said that if we continue on this path, the carnage we saw in various attacks on mosques, non-combatants and minorities in Lahore and other parts of Punjab will only gain strength.

“I want to know if we have abandoned the plan to disable the power of the terrorists operating out of the tribal agencies where the army is running a costly military operation, because by now all the militants have links with each other”, she added.

She said those who cannot escape across an open border with Afghanistan will come down to the Punjab and to Karachi. In fact, they already have. You cannot run a military operation in six tribal agencies and then have extremist ideologies run rampant in other areas.

The Punjab outfits may not have challenged the writ of the state as yet, but in reality they have devolved down to many splinters, with ties to al Qaeda, and they are gaining critical mass, she added.

Instead of reversing their momentum, a part of the government is patronising them. This is both short-sighted and dangerous, and can have serious consequences for both Pakistan, argued Rehman.

She advised the Punjab government to take back this grant and firm up its resolve to combat terrorism by reducing space for banned outfits, and by building governance capacity to administer its own social services or find non-violent partners who can deliver at the grassroots.

Previously when Punjab opposition MP Samina Khawar Hayat gave a disturbing statement while speaking on the issue of rising number of single women in the country who are in their 30’s (she gave the bizarre idea of encouraging married men to marry second time to help such women), however, she had to face a lot criticism from Dr Amna Buttar on the floor of the Punjab assembly and Ms Sherry Rehman in the national assembly. Dr Amna Buttar even went on to state that Ms Samina Hayat has insulted the woman of whole Muslim world but sadly on both these occasions the respective parliamentary party of PPP both at Punjab and center didn’t support these two brave women (Amna Buttar and Sherry Rehman) on the floor of the house.

About the author

Humza Ikram

9 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Such findings will be used for unfair means by these banned outfits, let there be no doubt about it. I don’t know if the provincial government had such surplus funds, there are so many civil society groups working in fields of education, health and human rights, they should have been supported.

  • Both the ladies Ms Sherry Rehman and Dr Amna Buttar have shown exemplary guts to question the aid being given to a terrorist outfit Jamat-ul-Dawa. We have over hundreds of charity organizations who sole task is the welfare of marginalized segments of society why not assist them? These terrorist outfits often take the disguise of charity organizations so to keep a legitimate front while on the other hand they keep killing the innocent civilians. The perturbing revival of such organizations calls for immediate action by the government.

  • i another sad news is that instead of giving funds to public school Punjab government is giving 82 million funds to elite boarding school of punjab “chand bagh” , which is just like a second aitchison college of lahore.

  • All Chand Baghs, Aitchisons, Beaconhouses, Lahore Grammars, etc must be dismantled and converted into public schools.

    Before that, however, the government must ensure appropriate teachers training program to improve and streamline the quality of education in all schools throughout Pakistan.

    All schools must follow only one set of curriculum disregarding all forms of liberal fascist and religious fascist interventions.

  • @ abdul . when governments starts giving funds to elite private school instead of increasing funds of public school . In way it shows that government itself acknowledged the fact that they can’t compete with them.