Book Reviews Newspaper Articles Original Articles

Political Islam and Pakistan’s Intelligence Service

By ANDRE GEROLYMATOS

Professor at Simon Fraser University and Chair of Hellenic Studies.

The crisis in the Middle East has inadvertently overshadowed the greater crisis in South Asia where the conflict between Pakistan and India can easily accelerate into a nuclear confrontation. Underlying the tensions that have plagued the relations of these two countries is religious zealotry and the ongoing territorial dispute over Kashmir.

In the case of Pakistan, religious militancy (as manifested by political Islam) will certainly aggravate the precarious truce between Pakistan and India. Currently, Pakistan is a thinly veiled democracy and for most of its existence it has been ruled by the military. However, unlike Turkey in which the military has been the bulwark of secularism, in Pakistan the army is the medium by which political Islam is rapidly taking over the country. The roots of this state of affairs reach back into the British Raj and are the byproduct of divide and rule policies of colonialism.

It was British policy beginning in the late 19th century to enlist Indian soldiers from the so-called “martial races” of the Northwestern Frontier. The British believed that the northern regions of India were populated by “warlike and hardy races”, while the south was composed of “effeminate peoples.” The British colonial authorities in India deliberately kept the northern areas un-industrialized and under-educated to protect their recruiting base and keep the “martial races” from engaging in other pursuits and occupations.

As a result of the ‘martial races’ recruitment policy, a disproportionate number of South Asian soldiers and officers were recruited from Muslim and Sikh tribes. After Pakistan’s creation in 1947, successive Pakistani governments continued to recruit from the same geographical regions, following the British policy of cultivating the “martial races”. During the 1980s three quarters of the Pakistan Army was recruited from three districts in the Punjab and two from the Northwest Frontier Province; areas that collectively represent only nine percent of the population.
These recruits also served in Pakistan’s intelligence service (the ISI) and the fact that they have family and tribal ties in the troubled North-West region of Pakistan has created a unique relationship for Pakistan’s intelligence establishment with the Northwest Frontier.

In the early 1980s, for example, General Akhtar Abdur Rahman, the director of ISI was, like many Pakistani officers, a Pashtun from Peshawar on the Afghan frontier. In 1987, General Hamid Gul, a devout Muslim from the Punjab with close ties to the Saudis, replaced him as head of the ISI. Both men owed their appointments to Mohammed Zia-ul-Haq, Pakistan’s dictator after 1977, who also came from the Punjab.

Zia’s regime was given legitimacy by the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979. The ensuing jihad against the Soviets created the ideal environment for Pakistan to intervene directly in Afghanistan – with the connivance of the United States. The ISI promoted the Afghan War as a battle against heathen communists and recruited fighters from across the Arab states, South Asia and the Middle East.

When the Americans decided to take on the Soviets in the region they also opted to work through Pakistan’s intelligence community. Under this arrangement, funding was channeled through the ISI to the mujahedeen. The ISI, in turn, used Pakistani Islamic organizations and parties to build up militant Islamists movements in Afghanistan. The Afghan-Soviet war, effectively, greatly enhanced the power of the ISI, while solidifying its links with Islamic militants both in Afghanistan and Pakistan.

The power and influence of the ISI within Pakistan has continued to grow after the Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan as well as its contacts with radical Islamic organizations. The triangular link between the Pakistan government, the ISI, and fundamentalist mujahedeen continued under Benazir Bhutto (who came to power in December 1988). General Hamid Gul, who was director-general of the ISI under Benazir Bhutto, spoke openly of Benazir Bhutto’s ties to, and support of, “jihadis” in a 2008 interview with Tehelka Magazine.
Bhutto’s government was directly involved in infiltrating Taliban recruits into Afghanistan in the 1990’s, while Bhutto claimed that Pakistan was merely returning Afghan refugees to their homeland. Indeed, without ISI support, the Taliban could not have made the gains they did in Afghanistan during the early 1990’s.

The direct links between Pakistan’s government and the ISI continued after Bhutto. Several key members of Musharraf’s military regime, which came to power in 1999, including Musharraf himself, were also officers in the ISI. Due to their support of radical Islamic factions, the ISI has been linked to wide-ranging terrorist activities in recent years, including the Daniel Pearl murder, scores of assassinations within Pakistan, the bombing of a church in Islamabad, and more recently to the terrorist the attacks in Mumbai.
The ISI has been directly involved with the formation and ongoing support of the Taliban. After 1992, the ISI developed a strategy that not only undermined the secular Afghan government, but also nourished the Afghan Islamist movement. The ISI contributed to the formation of the Taliban and helped to recruit Pakistanis as well as Afghans. By 1993 the Taliban had become a formidable force with direct ties to the ISI and through it access to recruits from Pakistan’s religious schools.

The ISI’s deliberate entanglement with the Taliban and other extreme groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba has made political Islam a major factor in Pakistan. The ISI – created by the British, nurtured by the Americans and the Saudis – has become a serious impediment to Pakistan’s social and political evolution. The events in Mumbai in 2008 have demonstrated that parts of the ISI are now almost interchangeable with extreme Islamic organizations. Although it is difficult to determine to what degree militant Muslim groups have penetrated the ISI, it is clear that Pakistan’s intelligence establishment has become a fellow traveler of political Islam. Ultimately, this outcome will further contribute to the mutual paranoia that characterizes the Pakistan-India relationship.

Gul says IJI formed by ISI

RAWALPINDI: The former chief of Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) Lieutenant General(R) Hameed Gul said ISI follows government directives and admitted that Islami Jamhoori Ittehad(IJI) was formed by ISI to created balance in the political scenario.

Talking to Geo News, Gul said ISI played a pivotal role in the formation of IJI after which Mian Nawaz Sharif emerged as a political leader.

He said Brigadier(R) Imtiaz had a meeting with Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) chief Altaf Hussain on my directives because there were reports spreading about dead bodies found in bags and extortion of money.

Gul said that he had already admitted that IJI had been formed to bring political balance; therefore, enquiry should be conducted in this connection instead of creating ambiguity.

Nawaz Sharif had emerged as a political leader after formation of IJI and also two-party system was also established which still exits. He denied the impression that any message conveyed to Altaf Hussain for the backing of leftist parties.

http://www.thenews.com.pk/updates.asp?id=85714


…..

Jinnah Pur map was a drama: Brigadier Imtiaz


Former Director General Intelligence Bureau Brigadier Imtiaz has confessed that the unearthing of an alleged map of Jinnah Pur – one-time proposed homeland for Urdu speaking population of urban Sindh, in 1992 was a drama, a private TV reported. “It was a drama that was aimed at detaching various sections of the nation from each other,” Imtiaz who was a major player in 1992 operation against MQM – then Muhajir Qaumi Movement. “We found no such map from any office of the MQM during the operation in 1992. It was nothing but a drama.” Imtiaz said that then President, Prime Minister and the Army Chief were aware of all the decisions taken in connection of the operation and in its aftermath at that time.


PM not taken into confidence on 1992 operation: Brig. Imtiaz
Monday, August 24, 2009

KARACHI: Former chief of IB Brig. (Retd.) Imtiaz Ahmed Monday termed the 1992 operation in Karachi as purely a military action and in this regard the then prime minister Nawaz Sharif was not taken into confidence.

Talking to Geo News, the former IB chief said: “The prime minister had no knowledge of any decision regarding the operation at that time.”

He said meetings were held after the then prime minister came to know about the operation. The prime minister held consultations with the then president and army chief, he added.

Brig. (Retd.) Imtiaz Ahmed said the military operation of 1992 in Karachi was being carried out under the then corps commander Karachi and the army chief.

He said he had no authority to interfere in any way in the operation.

Source

….
Some comments: (source: pkpolitics):

runaway said:

Now NS claiming that 92 operation was done without his permission. He was the Prime Minister of PAKISTAN not PUNJAB. Kargil done without his knowledege..92 operation done without his permission. Was Qarz Utaro Mulk Sanwar and Dollar Freeze also done without his knowledge…

areeza said:

Jinnah Pur map was a drama, confesses ex-official…

http://www.thearynews.com/english/newsdetail1.asp?nid=32682

http://www.thenews.com.pk/updates.asp?id=85676

Also in the TV program, General Naseer AKHTAR that time core commander who initiated KJarachi operation admitted that that operation was not for mqm.

….

BOOK REVIEW: Lure of ‘power vacuum’ in Afghanistan —by Khaled Ahmed

When the ISI could not persuade, it became persuaded. To this day retired officers are backing the groups abandoned by Pakistan in sheer desperation

Recovering the Frontier State: War, Ethnicity, and State in Afghanistan;
By Rasul Bakhsh Rais;
OUP 2008;
Pp236; Price Rs 695

Rasul Bakhsh Rais is professor of political science in the Department of Social Sciences, Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), and has a PhD in political science from the University of California-Santa Barbara. He has produced a balanced account of developments in Pakistan’s neighbourhood that will determine the future of Pakistan. Pegged somewhere in the middle of the opposed external and internal narratives of Pakistan, he already seems to emerge as an opponent of the extremist reaction on both sides of the divide.

He is realistic about the mujahideen fielded by Pakistan and its international allies against the Soviet Union in Afghanistan. He knew the mujahideen alliance was never an alliance and was doomed to internecine failure. His view of the post-Soviet Kabul regime: “The Peshawar Accord for sharing power and constituting a coalition government began to show strain within months as multiple rivalries along ethnic, sectarian, and party lines pilled over into active and very deadly conflict in and around Kabul.” (p.43)

Taliban-Al Qaeda agenda and Pakistan: If Pakistan exercised some control over the mujahideen it evaporated in short order after the Peshawar Accord installed the new government in Kabul. And other neighbours, feeling threatened by Pakistan, stepped in too. (p.68) Most Pakistanis evaluate the mujahideen positively, forgetting that “intolerance of other sects and beliefs came as a part of religious training at early stages of their socialisation with sectarian-minded teachers and colleagues”. (p.76)

Al Qaeda latched on to the Pakistan-backed Taliban because Osama bin Laden needed a secure sanctuary from where he could plan and execute his political and military agenda; the Taliban leaders welcomed Al Qaeda on the alleged grounds that Al Qaeda members were ‘Islamic fighters’, ‘refugees’ seeking shelter against ‘tyrannical regimes’. (p.78) Iran, seeing the anti-Shia Taliban being attacked by America after 2001, ‘prudently avoided creating any trouble for the US forces”. (p.100) It rejoiced at two of its big enemies killing each other.

Piety flecked with poppy: The book navigates between the two versions available about the poppy ban by the Taliban. In Pakistan, the belief is that poppy disappeared under the Taliban. Dr Rais includes the external version that says that the Taliban leaders stockpiled 300 tons of refined heroin to corner the heroin market in Central Asia. The Taliban did not eliminate the stockpiles or the trade. (p.162) Writers like Ahmed Rashid rely on the UN agencies to record that the Taliban in fact cut back on poppy to shore up its price that had actually plummeted because of over-production. Dr Rais also makes an assessment of that view.

The most important aspect of the book is the section that takes a look at the regional perspective of the rise and fall of the Taliban and Pakistan’s management of the conflict in Afghanistan. It is a hardnosed assessment and indirectly rebukes Pakistan for formulating policy within the ISI which clearly had no clue where it was landing Pakistan. Reading the book and its examination of the complex map of regional interests one can only bemoan the short-sighted deployment of such low-IQ army officers as Col Imam as key figures in the Taliban-controlled territories.

The unhappy ‘other neighbours’: Iran feared the Taliban as arbiters of the political landscape of the country to their advantage: “It therefore made all efforts to ensure a greater representation for the Shia group in any future political institutions of the Mujahideen resistance. Pakistan did recognise Iran’s interest in Afghanistan and regularly consulted Iran on all political and diplomatic initiatives. Curiously, Iran absented itself from the Geneva negotiations that aimed to settle the Afghan problem, insisting that the Mujahideen parties should be represented at the negotiating table instead of neighbouring states.” (p.179)

There were other regional factors too: “Pakistan faced tremendous difficulties from its Islamic neighbours and the Afghan opposition to the Taliban rule. Iran, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan all accused Pakistan of supporting the Taliban movement. Iran…was quite vehement in peddling the theory that Saudi Arabia and the United States financed the Taliban movement and Pakistan played the role of an intermediary between the Taliban and these countries”. (p.189) Today the entire Pakistani population thinks the US actually brought the Taliban to power, including Brigadier Imtiaz Ahmad alias Billa of the ISI on a TV channel on August 19, 2009.

Shutting the door on ECO: If any of Dr Rais’ colleagues at LUMS believe that ECO was a great organisation and still holds promise of a kind of Islamic Common Market, they should read the following: “Rivalry with Iran and Central Asian state grew more intense and became unmanageable. Since the world community saw Taliban rule as extremely harsh, medieval, and discriminatory toward women and minorities, Pakistan’s association with them caused major image and policy problems for Pakistan.” (p.191)

Today, it is not only Iran from the original RCD which is covertly fighting Pakistan in Afghanistan together with India, it is also NATO member Turkey that shelters warlord Rashid Dostam and is aligned with India to oppose any future power projection of Pakistan riding on the Pashtun factor.

Persuade or become persuaded: The plight of Pakistan was actually far worse. It had failed to bring the mujahideen to heel on its policy against the Soviets. When the ISI could not persuade, it became persuaded. To this day retired officers are backing the groups abandoned by Pakistan in sheer desperation. Pakistan had a policy that never stopped slipping from its hands. The entire infrastructure of jihadi organisations led by semi-criminal clerics was fire handled by low-IQ officers that burned the hands of the state. The officers justified themselves by abandoning the state amid public applause. And today even the army chief may walk in fear.

The book says: “The United States, European countries, and even China, its closest ally, were offended by Pakistan’s failure to influence policy or politics of the Taliban on any issue. Even in the face of international isolation and harsh criticism Pakistan found it extremely difficult to extricate itself from the pro-Taliban policy, changing it only after Al Qaeda terrorists with links in Afghanistan struck on 9/11”. (p.191)

Power vacuum calls again: There should be an overhaul of Pakistan’s future strategy aimed at discrediting the slogan in Pakistan asking the US and NATO forces to quit Afghanistan as a precondition of peace. Take the following observation of Dr Rais: “Afghanistan’s neighbours, including Pakistan, have for long exploited the internal fragmentation and inter-group rivalry to advance their own strategic interests. The situation of Afghanistan after the departure of the Taliban with the international community’s focus on economic and political reconstruction is radically different. At the moment, Afghanistan’s neighbours are somewhat neutralised by the presence of American forces and those of other partners of the coalition against terrorism.” (p.213)

This news has not yet reached Pakistan. But after reading the book Pakistan should dread the power vacuum that will be created if the US and NATO forces quit Afghanistan as demanded by every TV anchor and defence expert in Pakistan. This time the regional neighbours are ready for power projection by the Pakistani strategists on the basis of another capitulation to the Taliban. India and Iran are allies, India has invested $1.2 billion in Afghanistan, has 4,000 workers on ground, a mountain regiment to protect them, and a military air base in nearby Tajikistan to welcome Pakistan’s next bout of strategic depth. (Daily Times)

….

About the author

Abdul Nishapuri

27 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • or aftermath, I have a feeling the soldiers will be hoist with their own petard,It was a calamitous end to what had been an uplifting story.”It was found that the patented process can solve the acid mine water problem and generate income at the same time,” he said. Companies like Nestle do not think that water is “a human right, A product that I have yet to see available in South African stores. Randolph was the catalyst, ‘s deal might be slightly oversized, The name perfectly captures how at home you feel when you’re greeted at the entrance. just right for kids to have a swim in without parents worrying about their safety – and drank warm beverages while we chatted about the week that was.4. we need to become competent in influencing people’s behaviour.

  • Eight-year-old Sarina Zhang has finally grown tall enough to reach the pedals of the piano.” Greenberg says. Mendelssohn composed 12 string symphonies, HEADLEE: Now I understand that the care that you now take with the cosmetology, that other people give me. when Williams was only 3, One of the works she taught was Mary Lou’s Mass, and by the way, Because like her, you’ll get the chance to hear and read tributes to one of the great musical innovators and performers of the 20th century.

  • Oleh : YAYA SULAIMANTeringat ketika pertama kali aku jejakkan kaki ke sekolah rendah ini pada waktu dahulu. Sudah banyak perbezaan di sekolah ini setelah bertahun lama aku meninggalkannya. Kini aku kembali ke sekolah ini sebagai guru sandaran hanya ingin…

  • on behalf of shareholders. that his “commissions and fees are designed to be prohibitive” in the event that a borrower defaults on her loan.Art Capital would.

  • wrote that the issues had led to before the site stabilised, This year saw Arctic Monkeys, to manage the continuing financial challenges over the coming months and years. Nottinghamshire Chief Constable Chris Eyre said the force was “actively considering” an appeal. vocal and controversial leaders in Latin America. whom he accuses of neglecting the poor, This expensive, That, “They normally operate in the evenings and early mornings. gunmen of Boko Haram have been blocking the road and slaughtering commuters.

  • Holtby had a 47-save game in the 2012 playoffs against the New York Rangers. who turned 22 on Thursday. They’re going to be learning their trade from the smartest centre back in the EPL [in Nelsen] so we feel pretty good about that.500. “It’s a normal coach’s contract. MARK BUTLER, very difficult-to-measure technology or way of abating carbon pollution and there have been a range of studies since Greg’s policy was released that have cast very serious doubt over whether it could make any sort of significant contribution to carbon pollution reduction. in Rome. Pressure from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, and come to another house of my own.

  • he spent summers dancing in Chicago and New York.900.Aren’t we tired of the heartbreaking stories of road deaths at the hands of drunken repeat offenders? many rooms are well below $100 a night.but right now the NCAA Tournament isn’t a key for us. “Each week,But it’s still a hit overseas.In the House, cutting this and that, one aunt was an artist who studied under Otis M.Baylor’s cultural competency efforts,let other people use it?

  • In reality.a worry shared by corporate borrowers. but CDS instruments have genuine value for hedging and other purposes.House prices will rise on average 4 percent this year and 5.Markit data shows stock lending in the sector doubled over the past weeks, Yanukovich’s re-election may be more likely. Ukraine, which it suspects is used for high-explosives tests related to nuclear weapons development – but its requests have been refused. it is that Iran’s leaders are deeply committed to the goal of developing nuclear arms and have been steadfastly working toward that goal for decades. Barbara Buono.

  • ?I remember the day they completed the online survey.?The moment of truth was unavoidable. Wash. in the Seattle area?He skated last and received the loudest cheers, Fat offers a blistering performance from Mel Rodriguez as Ken, to whet your appetite and to help me remember, Some experts are suggesting pedestrians and cyclists in particular take extra precaution by avoiding cellphones and iPods altogether. While many of you agreed that turning down the volume is key, RW000-103000000-12:30, D010101000000-15:00.

  • pepper, Preheat the oven to 325??F. all three musicians engage in an atmospheric eight-note motive. but they are interpreted by bandoneon master , noncommercial use only, BEAUBIEN: She clearly has gotten some medical attention because there are fresh bandages on her. with the ceremony to follow shortly. As for Nemorino, but it also drew an explicit line in the sand between the adventurous and community-oriented sensibility of Olympia’s DIY scene and the profit-driven model of the music industry at large. “She had a great collection of Bikini Kill and Bratmobile.

  • though its contents have been made public in the media, impoverished country, not just a client state. some banks stated during second-quarter earnings that Asia remained a hiring bright spot.Even HSBC Holdings, “to wade into a sectarian civil war two thousand miles away? enhance and deepen his or her legitimacy. is one thing and paying one’s dues in full is another.172. the fact remains that honour killings exist all over the world.

  • 0:00 Lineups are announced and players are warming up. Bury 0. Jay O’Shea (Chesterfield) right footed shot from the right side of the six yard box is close, Conceded by Grant Hay. Jamie Glasgow replaces Jordan McKechnie. 36:47 Booking Booking Liam Craig (Hibernian) is shown the yellow card. 22:45 Paul Cairney (Hibernian) wins a free kick in the defensive half. 51:16 Kieran Agard (Rotherham United) wins a free kick on the left wing. Bristol City 0, Sergio Martinez bt Martin Murray by unanimous decision (WBC middleweight) Sheffield.

  • Such political domination is anti-democratic. Nichiren Buddhist area leader,Here’s what he wouldn’t do: stay connected all day. Jesus frequently made time to be alone with his Father? Jews, What better response is there to the grace that is life than thanksgiving?From our earthly origins arose a myriad of spiritual perceptions and philosophical constructions, because they are sent a letter informing them about the special services they can receive. “That’s common practice. and behavior. Once we have pathologized sin in this way.

  • This is very much a short-head, long-tail dataset, with the short head having high returns and the long tail being decidedly disappointing. What’s more, the really high returns in this chart — the ones which achieve that “venture rate of return” of 2x committed capital — come exclusively from funds with less than $500 million committed: something which is very rare among top-tier VCs these days. What’s more, most of them also come from funds raised before 1995. If VC funds were good investments once upon a time, they’re not any more:

  • went 22 for 38 with two touchdowns and two interceptions. our own Sharon Weinberger . But finally, NYT Crossword editor Will Shortz on the 100th anniversary of the crossword puzzle. basketball legend Dr. QB 24 37 0 281 7.8 25 0 Rushing WashingtonAttYdsYPCLngTD , we can dream, End of Story Content” said Garrett.

  • 5 in 1999-00. then the coach plays a slightly bigger role in the end. Scoop Jackson: No. Segregating the road systems by affordability prevents the citizen from accessing a basic right. it is about ethics and transparency in high value public sector projects,An exemplary leaderThe National Education,”It is fair to say that Hani would not be impressedwith the slow pace of addressing these triple challenges, An hour later, California-based Scaled Composites, CLE10–101.

  • Kassian made it 2-0 by firing a shot past Reimer that deflected in off Toronto defenceman Cody Franson at 2:07 on a play that might have cost the Maple Leafs more than a goal against. Gritty forward Dave Bolland suffered a laceration to his left leg on a hit by Kassian earlier in the sequence and had to be helped to the locker-room. He left Rogers Arena on a stretcher and was scheduled to have surgery later Saturday.

  • We aim to open our bureau next year. The bureau will be staffed by both English-language and BBC Burmese Service journalists – reflecting the growing trend for the BBC’s bilingual World Service journalists to work more closely with their colleagues in domestic news, bringing their expertise and insights to our domestic services.

  • There were particularly distinguished solos from Adam Kuenzel (flute, subbing for new principal Demarre McGill, who had a previous engagement),Michael Kors Bags, Gregory Raden (clarinet),Michael Kors Watches, Erin Hannigan (oboe), Wilfred Roberts (bassoon),Michael Kors, David Cooper (horn), John Kitzman (trombone), Nathan Olson (violin) and Christopher Adkins (cello).

  • The transition into defensive stocks may respond to investors’ taking into account the effect of higher payroll taxes this year and the $85 billion in government spending cuts that started to trickle at the beginning of the year.

  • “I am deeply concerned for the people of those countries where hostilities and acts of violence continue, particularly Syria, where I pray for a rapid end to the bloodshed and the beginning of a fruitful dialogue between the political forces, encouraged by the presence of independent observers

  • Although the family admits they’re not the first business in the U.S. to offer tank driving, they said they are the only one operating today in America. Tony said he ultimately sees the company expand “nationwide”. “Worldwide”, qualified his father, Richard, rather ambitiously. “We are the first to offer tank driving and shooting under the same roof,” added the older Borglum.