Original Articles

“Get’em through Interpol”, whispers Beena Sarwar to Rehman Malik – by Ismail Effendi

Recently, two Pakistani bloggers who are based in North America have informed me that noted “liberal” activist and coordinator of Jang Group’s Aman Ki Asha project, Beena Sarwar, is running a concerted campaign to locate and harass bloggers associated with LUBP.  Her program with Rehman Malik is a proof of this. This employee of Jnag group (which has a history of harassing LUBP) has already driven away some LUBPians and forced others to go underground and desist their activitiy.

In a recent report on Social Media Mela 2012 which was also attended by Rehman Malik, Beena Sarwar writes:

Some tweeps (as twitter users are called) using fake IDs do upload photographs (sometimes not their own) so they don’t show up as eggs, and some use fake IDs due to security reasons. But the bottom line is that those who spoil the ‘twitmosphere’ with their divisive and abusive comments are rotten eggs. Rehman Malik called upon both the governments to take action against those who hide behind fake identities to abuse, bully and threaten others. He also announced that the Ministry of Interior was planning a big social media conference in Islamabad, which he was trying to get Interpol to also attend.

The coordinated actions of Beena Sarwar and Rehman Malik are clear proof of the fact that they want to shut down LUBP and that ShiaKilling.com, PakShia.com, and other pro-Baloch, pro-Ahmadi websites remain threatened. And that ‘uncomfortable blogs’ are placed firmly in the control of the Interior Ministry if they survive.

Expatriate Pakistanis are deeply concerned about the ongoing Shia Genocide in Pakistan. Two of my closest friends in the expat community are from Balochistan – one is a secular Baloch Nationalist and the other is a Shia Hazara. In our discussion, we were deeply disturbed by the various distortions in this issue as well as NGO entrepreneurs selling and distorting our misery to make money.

All three of us are big fans of LUBP. Two of us (including myself) could have been recently counted as PPP supporters and our Baloch friend was also sympathetic to PPP while being a BNP supporter.  That is no longer the case. And what saddens one even further is that those who speak for the marginalized communities are being marginalized and witch-hunted.

The duo of Beena Sarwar and Rehman Malik seem to have been irked by their criticism so much that perhaps on the insistence of the former and her kind that she represents, the latter has even decided to contact Interpol to take action against those who according to them “hide behind fake identities to abuse & bully others”. Beena herself, either superciliously or superficially, has stated so in her Aman ki Asha blog.

It is a travesty of everything human to even think that in a country where terrorists like Malik Ishaq roam freely, the interior minister would belabour himself with witch-hunting a few anonymous writers through not only FIA, but even Interpol. This Gestapao tactic is being coordinated to ensure a successful censorship, while ironically, at least Beena who seems to be the mother of the idea, pretends to be a champion of freedom of expression and a human rights activist.

LUBPians, please be careful.  The knives are being sharpened to get you.

On a similar note, one might as well remind Rehman Malik that if he is really sympathetic to the Peoples Party. He should try to perform his job better by catching terrorists than trying to go after bloggers. In the current government, between 4000 – 7000 Shia Muslims have been systematically targeted and killed.  Hundreds of Baloch youth have been killed and the moderate Baloch leadership (Professor Saba Dashtyari etc) have been wiped out in the most brutal manner possible.

Not only are we getting killed like flies in Pakistan, even the sites that grieve and inform about our suffering are being shut down.  First it was alislam.com the Ahmaddiyah Muslim website.  A few days later it was ShiaKilling.com and PakShia.com.  Principled activists from LUBP, Al Ufaq, Pakistan Blogzine and others were the most eloquent in raising their voice against these Gestapo tactics by the interior ministry. I have been informed that several letters have been written to PPP leadership.  Many of them are known to be sympathetic moderates who feel for Shia Genocide, Baloch suppression and Ahmadi Persecution.

However, instead of immediately restoring ShiaKilling website, Rehman Malik sprinkled salts on the wounds of the targeted Shia community accusing them of putting “objectionable material” on the banned Shia websites.

Excuse me! The only thing that is OBJECTIONABLE is the Gestapo tactics of Rehman Malik.  He said nothing about the hate material that is causing Shia Genocide (websites of SSP that are detailed in Rusty Walker post) but is now essentially telling the Shias that they must NOT catalogue their genocide.  While Rehman Malik is blaming the victims, the Shias, he is completely silent on websites that preach murderous hatred against Shias.

No longer can the PPP hide behind the ISI/military establishment/Judiciary and pretend that they are not culpable. Rehman Malik has seen to that.  One might even say that in Balochistan, Rehman Malik and CM Raisani have ensured that PPP has lost support.  They have made disgusting statements against both Shias and the Baloch Nationalists. This is certainly, and unfortunately, going to deplete the PPP vote bank.

In Karachi, many PPP loyalists see Rehman Malik as an extension of ISI-MQM.  His cruel and failed operation in the former PPP stronghold of Lyari has destroyed PPP’s electoral base in Karachi.  His henchman Wassan is no longer there but Rehman Malik is.  In Gilgit-Baltistan, once another PPP stronghold, support has plunged due the biased manner that Rehman Malik handled the Chillas massacre of the Shias.

While the sacrifice of one black goat and 10 Shias a day might save this weak government for another few months, don’t expect the Baloch, GB, Pashtun and Shia vote anymore.

For further proof that PPP is losing support look no further that LUBP’s main page. I don’t agree with Ikhtiar sahib’s choice of words for the title but I feel his pain.  He is doing a great service to the party by making them realize the pain of Shias.  He is making the party leadership aware that they are loosing their sypmpathy with the  public.  LUBP must not censor Ikhtiar otherwise one of Pakistan’s last bastion of hope in terms of freedom of speech stands to get squashed.  As for Farhad Jarral’s post it is insensitive and no different from the tactics of Rehman Malik and Beena Sarwar. Who is he to dictate how Shias mourn or inform about their suffering! His more-loyal-than-the-king type post will only hurt PPP.



Advisor to Prime Minister on Interior, Rehman Malik on Wednesday directed Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) to take legal action against those who pasted objectionable material on Shia Website.

Issuing directions, he warned all such elements to remove objectionable material from the Web pages immediately.

He further directed Director General FIA to submit a report in this regard after talking necessary cognizance to such offence.

The website, www.shiakilling.com, monitors and maintains a “death count” of Pakistani Shia Muslims targeted in sectarian violence.

It was banned by the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA), which operates on the directives of the Ministry of Information.

Upon attempting to access the website, users were met with a “Access denied” message, a usual occurrence for banned websites.

The Shia Action Committee on Tuesday protested on the alleged ban of the website.

The protestors, who were reportedly in hundreds chanted anti-government slogans . Police tried to stop them, which led to an altercation between both parties.

Another Shia website, pakshia.com, has also been reportedly banned by the PTA.

Source: http://dawn.com/2012/07/18/malik-directs-fia-to-inquire-ban-on-shia-website/


گزشتہ دنوں ریلی کے حوالے سے شیعہ کلنگ ہر شیعہ بلخصوص غیور نوجوانوں کا شکر گزار ہے۔ اُن تنظیموں،اداروں اور علماء کرام کے بھی شکر گزار ہے جنہوں نے شیعہ کلنگ کے ساتھ اظہار یکہجہتی کیا۔

اس کے علاوہ ہم تمام ایس ایم ایس سروس، اور سوشل نیٹ ورکنگ سے وابستہ اُن گروپس بلخصوص LUBP اور PSP کا شکریہ ادا کرتے ہے کہ اس مشکل وقت میں جب سب نے ساتھ چھوڑ دیا تو آپ نے شیعہ کلنگ کے ساتھ اظہار یکہجہتی کیا

Source: Shia Killing


شیعہ کلنگ انتظامیہ سمجھتی ہے کہ شیعہ کلنگ کی ویب سائٹ کی بندش کے حوالے سے رحمان ملک کا بیان ایک سازش ہے۔ اس کا مقصد صرف حکومت پر ملت تشیعُ کی جانب سے بڑھتے ہوئے پریشر کو کم کرنا اور انٹر نیشنل میڈیا کو خاموش کروانا ہے۔

ہمیں اب اس حکومت کے کسی بھی بندے پر بھروسہ نہیں۔ سب جھوٹے ہے, سب دھوکے باز ہے۔

Shia Killing Administration thinks that the statement of Mr. Rehman Malik about blocking of Shia Killing website is a conspiracy. Its motive is only reduction of pressure from government, which is created by Millat-e-Jafferia and divert the concern and shut the mouth of International media.

Now we don’t have trust on any person of this government. Everyone is liar and cheat.


Karachi:Rally against blocking of website Shiakilling.com; violence on bloggers and their supporters

About the author

Jehangir Hafsi


Click here to post a comment
  • Interpol to arrest those bloggers who use pen names? and divide liberals?

    In the past Beena has used similar language against pen names (Fake IDs in her language) who divide liberals.


    What are Rehman Malik and Beena Sarwar smoking?

  • Perhaps Ms. Beena Sarwar also referred to mention Laibaah of Pakistan Blogzine and other rotten eggs that usually spoil urban elites informative debates on Marxism and social justice in Avari Hotel’s lobbies.




  • Riaz Ali Toori ‏@RiazToori
    After taking brave action & bold stance against the ban of #Shia website, @SenRehmanMalik is being threatened & abused, we stand by him.

  • These people are unbelievably insecure. They seriously need to get a life. If LUBP criticizes you, you can respond back in the same manner. Using interpol to get bloggers?
    Kudos to Beena Sarwar and Rehman Malik

  • Good one by Beena S. You go girl otherwise this LUBP will mess up our funding.

  • Disgusting post. I was attending Social media forum and bcos no LUBPians were there, this post is like u know sour grapes. Childish. SOCMM12 was like so cool. Got to meet all the coolest Socialists and communists of Pakistan. Gotta say there is nothing like discussing who was more relevant while choosing between chickens tikka and lamb chops. Was Marx more relevant or was it Engels or Tariq Ali. Tariq Ali was definitely the cutest. After attending Socmm12, I realized that one can make a decent living as an activist/blogger or even a human rights activist. I just wish I was in Isloo or Lahore; this way I too could have comped a room at Avari. The food was great and I hope Beena gets all the LUBP idiots.

  • Could anything get any brazenly ridiculous than this? Rehman Malik contacting Interpol to locate and nab those who ‘hide behind the pen names’. For heaven’s sake, what are you smoking? What’s wrong? And of all, HAS PPP LOST ITS SANITY? Not even a single PPP MNA or MPA or stalwart to speak on this matter to the party leadership? What’s up with AAZ? Fine. Someone who is not bothered by the ruthless killing of Shias all around the country, do we expect him to stand for a few ‘writers with pen names?’ Also, someone of Farhad Jarral’s ilk in the party is more worrying than reassuring. If a shockingly naive card-carrying member with all his bone-chilling sentimentality is to brief the leadership of what’s going on social media, then I see no hope. PPP needs massive restructuring as far as the selection of right people for the big responsibilities within the party, and running its affairs. Otherwise it will slowly stagnate, dwindle and eventually disappear.

    Be warned, PPP. For God’s sake!

  • This article is an eye opener. Beena Sarwar is promoted as a human rights champion by the media. So for her, the danger is not from Jihadi websites but from bloggers using pen names who right about Ahmadiyya and Shia rights. The way Ms. Sarwar uses the word “divisive”, she is saying that she and her friends will not tolerate dissent. Shame on Beena. Never expected this from her. This is very depressing.

  • LUDP at it again. First you went after Ansar Abbasi and we stayed silent,

    Then you went after Samad Khurram and we barely threatened you

    Then you exposed Hamid Mir and Ejaz Haider and we could only abuse you while defending them

    Then you critisized Raza Rumi and Marvi Sirmed and we could only malign you

    Now you have highlighted Beena’s harassment so prepare to have your a—s handed to you in a plate

  • Institute Local Elections so that men & women tougher than Malik Ishaq, who cannot be sidelined by the military establishment rise up through the ranks of the PPP to form a protective wall for the vulnerable people of Pakistan.

    I do not know why the fuck Rehman Malik was allowed to become relevant in 2007, and I still do not understand why the fuck he is still there. I don’t know what the hell Asif Ali Zardari sees in this bagman.

  • @TLW

    Typical liberal posturing. Abuse Rehman Malik of the PPP instead of Beena Sarwar whose instigating this idiotic, juvenile attempt at getting back at Nishapuri or Laibaah or whomever the hell has managed to piss of her or one of her friends. BS (Just realised how prescient her initals are!) has a habit of rumour mongering herself. Last year, she had tweeted news of a whole bus of Muhajirs disappearing in Karachi during a periodic burst in ethnic killings in the city. Only stopped saying so when I clarified the news was a dirty rumour spawned by Geo News. But its understandable to lose objectivity when YOUR people are threatened, really or otherwise.

  • [url=http://caslowpitch.com/team/cheap-nike-foamposite.aspx]cheap foamposites[/url] So you need not worry about your boots when you are crossing a small stream or puddles of water in the street.. [url=http://caslowpitch.com/team/cheap-nike-foamposite.aspx]cheap foamposites[/url] The boots will remain as it is because of its water proof features and the ultimate effect of your feet also being kept dry..

    [url=http://caslowpitch.com/team/cheap-nike-foamposite.aspx]http://caslowpitch.com/team/cheap-nike-foamposite.aspx[/url] The Pome duck boots are abrasion resistant, water proof protection and paddled collar especially around the ankle to make it a more c comfortable fit.. [url=http://caslowpitch.com/team/cheap-nike-foamposite.aspx]cheap foamposites[/url] The presence of heavy duty laces with rust proof protection made it a more durable material thus providing maximum foot support..

    [url=http://caslowpitch.com/team/cheap-nike-foamposite.aspx]Cheap Nike Foamposite[/url] All these unique features have made Pome boots so popular now among the city commuters as it is serving them to the best of their satisfaction… [url=http://caslowpitch.com/team/cheap-nike-foamposite.aspx]nike foamposite for sale[/url] Do you know what to buy your women this Christmas? Christmas is fast approaching and like so many men, you are dreading it! The reason being is you have to buy many of presents! The hardest task is selecting a present for your woman..

    [url=http://caslowpitch.com/team/cheap-nike-foamposite.aspx]cheap foamposites[/url] Women are so sensitive and demanding that you have to be aware of the importance of the present and the affects it will have on her.. [url=http://caslowpitch.com/team/cheap-nike-foamposite.aspx]cheap foamposites for sale[/url] Don’t fear because whatever her age we have many great gift ideas guaranteed to make your woman happy!..

    [url=http://bbs2.rss.game.tw/home.php?mod=space&uid=29441]Rumours, Manipulating In Addition To The Sports Shoes[/url]
    [url=http://www.livejournal.com/]Find The Scoop Around Sneakers Before You’re Too Late[/url]
    [url=http://www.shopping-time.co.in/WB/Bankura/IFB-MELODIOUS-179-School-Danga,170817.html]Our Own Idiot’s Guide To Shoes Simplified[/url]
    [url=http://daten.ws-mack.de/gaestebuch.asp?n=schneemaenner&bp=schneemaenner.de/images/hintergrund.jpg&l=0&b]Gossip, Manipulating And Then Sports Shoes[/url]

  • [url=http://www.experienceliquid.com/EntityHelper/kobe-shoes.aspx]Kobe 9 Shoes[/url] The famousness of the LV brand name has arrived at these kinds of an extent that the signature LV emblem is regarded in almost ever louis vuitton outlLouis Vuitton Zippy Wallet M60049louis vuitton diaper bag for salelouis vuitton outlet nylouis vuitton epi leather bags like this one is only a fraction of the price compared to an authentic designer Louis Vuitton bag, just see for yourself! If I had a nickel for For the reason that the bag was actually considered to be configured for each brand that category icon, the excitement carries his personal appeal and focus on his identity.. [url=http://www.experienceliquid.com/EntityHelper/kobe-9-shoes.aspx]Kobe Bryant Shoes 2014[/url] Expansion of the high-flying name many kinds of fashion handbags and exquisite handbags and Louis Vuitton wallets said..

    [url=http://www.experienceliquid.com/EntityHelper/kobe-sneakers.aspx]kobe Sneakers[/url] Over the past 10 years, Louis Vuitton has made a mark in the world make clothing.. [url=http://www.experienceliquid.com/EntityHelper/kobe-shoes.aspx]Kobe 9 Shoes[/url] Cheap Louis Vuitton Women is Handbags If you chat with Louis Vuitton more, to every new collection of handbags, classic bags, purses and handbags..

    [url=http://www.experienceliquid.com/EntityHelper/kobe-9-shoes.aspx]http://www.experienceliquid.com/EntityHelper/kobe-9-shoes.aspx[/url] This famous producer makes more or less suitable handbags handbags and wallets.. [url=http://www.experienceliquid.com/EntityHelper/kobe-sneakers.aspx]Kobe Shoes[/url] Manufacturer and portfolio handbag Louis Vuitton are allowed in France..

    [url=http://www.afraso.org/en/content/zambias-economic-strategy-%E2%80%93-beyond-populist-attitudes-toward-china-and-south-africa/]Rumours, Manipulating Together With Sports Shoes[/url]
    [url=http://sunglasses.zomazi.com/104-ray-ban-wayfarer.html]Access The Scoop Around Sneakers Before You Are Too Late[/url]
    [url=http://lakeridgecommunity.com/children/2014/5/23/soap-box-derby-and-photography-camps-july-7-11.html]Discover The Insiders Info On Sneakers Before You’re Too Late[/url]
    [url=http://www.tristatetelecom.com/index.asp]The Idiot’s Manual For Shoes Explained[/url]