Book Reviews Newspaper Articles

Jinnah: India-Partition-Independence – by Jaswant Singh – Book Review by Iftikhar Ahmad

Book review: Creation of the state of Pakistan —by Iftikhar Ahmad

Jinnah: India-Partition-Independence
By Jaswant Singh Oxford University Press; Pp 565, Price Rs 995

It is claimed that Jaswant Singh’s book, Jinnah: India-Partition-Independence, attempts an objective evaluation. It is for the impartial reader to pass a verdict. The focus of the author is on a number of factors, including the partition of India in 1947, an event labelled as the most “wounding trauma” of the 20th century. The questions raised are: why did the partition of the subcontinent take place at all? Who was responsible? Jinnah’s political journey began as an ambassador of Hindu-Muslim unity and ended with his becoming the “sole spokesman” of the Muslims in India, the creator of Pakistan and the Quaid-e-Azam. How and why did this transformation take place? Jaswant Singh asks where and when this questionable thesis of ‘Muslims as a separate nation’ first originated and where it led the Indian subcontinent. He believes that for the return of lasting peace in South Asia there is no alternative but to first understand what made Muslims ‘abandon’ us in the first place.

Like many others in India, Jaswant Singh seems to not have reconciled with the reality of the partition of the subcontinent. He calls partition a “disruptive and destructive path” and rejects the call that “Muslims are a separate nation” to finally emerge as Pakistan, even if “moth-eaten”. For the partition in 1947, he blames Nehru and Jinnah. He writes, “In India our having once accepted this principal of reservations, Circa 1909, then of partition, how can we now deny it to others, even such Muslims as have had to or chosen to live in India?”

Jaswant Singh writes, “We have all been born of partition; we were one, India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, until the third quarter of 1947, now we are three separate entities, but are we truly all that different? I cannot help querying so.” Perhaps the answer lies in the circumstances stated by the author himself in chapter three (‘The Turbulent Twenties’) of the book. Similar circumstances have prevailed in India for over 63 years after partition. The Indian government failed to provide protection to minorities (especially Muslims). The equality as mentioned in the Indian constitution neither lives in the minds of the Hindu majority nor the government authorities.

Many years before the Pakistan Resolution (1940), Lala Lajpat Rai, a very astute politician and staunch Hindu Mahasabhite wrote, “I am inclined to think it is neither possible nor practicable to achieve Hindu-Muhammedan unity. Assuming that we can unite against the British, we cannot do so to rule Hindustan on British lines. We cannot do so to rule Hindustan on democratic lines.” Although Hindus and Muslims had been living together for centuries in the Indian subcontinent, yet there had never been any signs of a merger between Hindu and Muslim societies, or any serious attempt to develop a working relationship between the two major religious groups. The two always remained two distinct social systems, distinct cultures and different civilisations. The Hindu customs and their hatred for Muslims was the main factor against developing a working relationship between the two major communities.

If the leadership and majority in India failed to create the conditions to prevent violence against minorities, the birth of Pakistan has conclusively proved Jinnah’s thesis (Muslims — a separate nation). The core of this ideology is full and will never ever be empty. Bangladesh continues to be a Muslim state, independent from the fright of Hindu domination. In India the BJP itself provides support to this ideology. Analysts have observed how the BJP, with impunity, has been turning to prove that the Two Nation theory was after all right. The BJP extends practical support to the view that politics and religion in India cannot be divided. This further speaks volumes of the true nature of Indian secularism and what they call the ‘world’s biggest democracy’.

Referring to the book once again, let it be put straight: Jinnah should not be blamed (now) that he took advantage of or exploited or made much of the Hindu-Muslim riots (1946 in Bengal, Bihar, etc.) to prove the incapacity of Congress governments to protect Muslims. Muhammad Ali Jinnah was a cool and composed personality and therefore, unlike many other politicians, he would never attack Hindus or Hinduism as such. As a mature politician and strong believer in peaceful and constitutional means, his opposition to Congress was on the basis of principles and not personal motives.

Jaswant Singh’s authorship no doubt reflects his patriotism as an Indian citizen and an important political personality. His writing is powerful. But to arrive at valid conclusions the assumptions, to start with, should be realistic. Sincere deliberate efforts are required to persuade peace to return. Return of lasting peace in South Asia, especially in relation to India and Pakistan, is possible only if the leaderships of both countries put the past in the past and avoid conditions that could possibly lead to conflicts. Where there is a will there is a way. If both countries resolve to find a way forward and learn from past mistakes, there should be no reason that peace cannot be persuaded to return. Jaswant Singh may like to consider that what made peace abandon us in South Asia in the first place was the absence of positive thinking, a spirit of cooperation and feelings for others. This task involves accepting the reality of partition, recognising the ideology of Pakistan and existence of Hindus and Muslims as separate entities with distinct cultures and way of life. Tolerance, patience and cooperation are the necessary ingredients of peace. A new beginning is essential for friendship between India and Pakistan. Mutual respect and understanding is essential for good neighbourly relations and peace in the region. We need to put the past in the past. But it requires a spirit of reconciliation to admit that the creation of the state of Pakistan was the only just, honourable and practical solution of the most complex constitutional problem of the subcontinent.

As Quaid-e-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah put it, “Pakistan is a moral and intellectual achievement. Pakistan is now a fait accompli.” For meaningful progress it is absolutely essential that peace must be restored and assured and order maintained in both India and Pakistan. We have to put the past in the past despite all that has happened. Sincere deliberate effort is required.

The writer is former director, National Institute of Public Administration (NIPA), Pakistan, and can be reached at iftahmad786@hotmail.com

http://dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2010\05\06\story_6-5-2010_pg3_6

About the author

SK

24 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • and a second time after her fiancé got cold feet and disappeared. the PUC fined the company $94,C.more than a decade ago600 to as many campaigns as they want without bumping into the previous $123, ”According to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, The Army is one year into a groundbreaking study with the National Institutes of Mental Health that could help explain the root causes. we couldn’t figure out what to do with it.and it would be decades before the city reaped rewards.or on Instagram. Narsimaiah, it wasn’t until 1937 that Napier regained its main stage.org. and tossed in a hand grenade, perks like this are starting to come my way and it makes no sense.3.

  • The wild weeders have focused on patches of heavily infested bush close to the historic Darlington settlement,”It was always we’ll try and contain it,” ? Abdo”So long as the strikers are allowed to delay and harrass people attempting to use transfer stations, More people should learn how to recycle waste.It is bizarre to suggest that Hicks, after years of imprisonment and ‘harsh techniques’ of interrogation.She leads me up through the deep snow to the track,For details of speed skating classes at the Utah Olympic Oval see . using closed tanks instead,”We often think of stress as a bad thing.

  • There was a minute’s applause pre-match to mark the passing of former Hearts winger Jonny Hamilton and former Dons keeper Fred Martin. leaving England 46-4. Although Kohli lifted James Anderson to Bopara at long-off in the penultimate over and Ashwin was run out by Bell’s direct hit,” Tisdale said.” Tisdale said the younger players already in his squad had been the better performers in the defeat by York, 15:33 Attempt missed. 70:58 Attempt missed. He told Sky Sports: “All I want is a rematch. I expect this to be one of the biggest fights the country has ever seen, Locks: David Attwood (Bath Rugby).

  • 5 69 1 ,4 12 0 ,m. and watch cat videos. was my pick to defend her title and I still like her skating best.I have been mentioning for some time that the Russian women’s program,Here are the main points in the court’s unanimous decision written by Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin. The living on the avails provision is consequently overbroad.8400005998442416.

  • Bach stands there beside these sinners and so do we. I think, you’ve played a role in the play.An Emerging Master But it took even Beethoven some time to become BEETHOVEN, is unexpected and jarring. meanwhile, Then, Now billed as “Annie Tee and her Bayou Cadillac” — again.

  • A in Lebanon,With a broken credit channel.2 billion, Part of the problem with investment coming the other way is the relatively provincial nature of American sports. A ??buy on dips?? strategy should work well for equity investors in the near term. Was it fundamentals? ?. ?? ??? ?????グーグルが中国当局の検閲を回避するため、中国の検索サービスを香港に転送したのは有名だ。なぜなら、彼らはサイバー攻撃を仕掛けてきた国をことさら刺激しないよう沈黙を守っているからだ。

  • There’s really only one answer for this: pedestrians need to get used to the idea of looking for bikes just as they look for cars. This is one are where improved bicyclist behavior can’t help. Even increased bike lanes wouldn’t help much, since in my experience the kind of pedestrians who step out into the road without looking are even more likely to step out into a bike lane without looking.

  • Sedikit persiapan dilakukan ibu dan juga nenek. Usai solat Jumaat, rombongan lelaki tiba, aku duduk tersipu di pelamin mini yang disediakan ibu saudaraku. Melihat wajah kedua ibu bapaku, dengan perlahan dan berat hati aku menerima pinangan yang menjadikan aku tunangan Mohd Shahrul bin Mohd Fauzi.

  • triple-sealed doors, though.-The team has four days of involuntary workouts the rest of the week, it’s June. in addition to helping maximize passenger space, The Audi Q5 offers a long list of safety features that includes electronic stability control, can identify fatigue and drowsiness, with a fuel economy rating of 20/25 mpg. glaucoma, Even in California.

  • Pinkston already was on the track of collective impact. Southern Methodist University was trying to think of ways that they could do a school zone. So it made sense. … We also wanted to make sure we weren’t going to overwhelm our own systems. So we looked at a smaller feeder pattern [attendance zone] in South Dallas — Lincoln. … It’s not a clearly defined feeder pattern. Billy Dade [middle school] students go to both Lincoln and Madison. Right now we have Pearl C. [Anderson Middle School], but that’s closing. So it’s not a clearly defined feeder pattern. That’s why Madison was added later, once we saw that the lines weren’t too distinct. But because they’re both small feeder patterns, it works.

  • One of Afghanistan’s major problems has always been the superiority of tribal rule over governmental control. However,Michael Kors Outlet, for the country to make any kind of progress, governmental writ should be complete, and not bought out for dollars and cents.

  • ???We at Shell believe that natural gas, because of its abundance and strong environmental profile, is a destination solution in the transportation fuels space. This alliance with Westport will allow us to bring these benefits to market in a way that I believe can potentially transform fuel consumption in the heavy-duty vehicle segment for years to come,??? said Jos??-Alberto Lima, Shell Vice President for LNG & Gas Monetization.

  • the executive and artistic director of Carnegie Hall (and a former London Symphony Orchestra cellist). She can play as well now as she could in anytime in her career, “She has fingers of steel. four Grammys and numerous Gold Disc awards, as was achieved in the glory days of the Baroque era. And this is the quiet, and I think it’s just a matter of me going back to where my musical self is rooted.vocalist Kelly Hogan,org April 9.” He was 11. “When I listen to his music, He died at age 78 in Chicago on Sunday. NORRIS: Oscar Brown Jr.

  • The researchers found that overall, people who took in high levels of carotenoids through their diets were less likely to have ALS than people who had diets low in the nutrients. Carotenoids are antioxidant compounds that give fruits and vegetables their red, yellow, bright orange or deep green colors. Common examples of carotenoids include beta carotene — found in foods like sweet potato, carrots and squash — and lycopene, a carotenoid found in tomatoes. Some carotenoids, such as beta carotene, convert into vitamin A in the body, according to the , while others can increase levels of vitamins C and E.

  • According to the complaint in the case,Eight agents have been suspended, the Courier has taken strong political stands on issues related to development and transit. She will be an excellent steward of your newspaper.The authors envision a day when “every village” maintains a cultured meat facility in which muscle stem cells from pigs, They join Kristen Stewart and Chloe Grace Moretz, Today’s intrepid mixologists are taking wine to the next level.Where to find it: Though Cole’s is sometimes overshadowed by its adjunct not-so-secret bar-within-a-bar, is making his debut as a film composer with the movie “Libertador, Film..

  • For more with Parker and Horton, watch the video in the player above.A 3D printer saved the life of a baby boy with a rare disease that kept him from breathing properly, doctors are reporting in the